CONTENTS
Play Showcases Talents of Persephone Theatre’s Young
Company
Raising Awareness During Missing Persons Week
School Holiday Lunch Highlights Staff’s Dedication to Their
Students
Singers Are Ambassadors of Philippine Culture and
Friendship
Advisory Council Works toward Economic Reconciliation
Partnership Will Help Indigenous People Find Natural
Resource Sector Jobs
Opposition’s Positions on Corporate Donations and Carbon
Tax
Management of Provincial Economy
Hospital Parking Fees and Management of Health Care System
Overdose Deaths and Treatment for Addictions
PRESENTING REPORTS BY STANDING AND SPECIAL COMMITTEES
Standing Committee on Intergovernmental Affairs and Justice
FOURTH
SESSION — TWENTY-NINTH LEGISLATURE
of
the
Legislative Assembly of Saskatchewan
DEBATES
AND PROCEEDINGS
(HANSARD)
N.S. Vol. 65 No. 55A Tuesday, April
30, 2024, 13:30
[The
Assembly met at 13:30.]
[Prayers]
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Parks,
Culture and Sport.
Hon.
Ms. L. Ross: — Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker.
Mr. Speaker, to you and through you, seated in the Speaker’s gallery, it’s my
pleasure to introduce a group of very special guests to our Legislative
Assembly.
Joining us today are the University of
the Philippines Madrigal Singers, who are in Saskatchewan as part of their
national tour. With them are members of the Saskatchewan Filipino community,
members of the Philippine Artists Circle, and members of the delegation who are
supporting their journey.
The University of the Philippines Madrigal
Singers are renowned internationally for their unparalleled talent and passion
dedicated to the art of choral music. Earlier today the choir graciously
performed here in our Legislative Building. It was truly outstanding and their
voices filled the rotunda with joy. It was absolutely breathtaking.
This occasion provides an excellent
opportunity to celebrate the deep cultural ties between the Philippines and
Saskatchewan. And through their performance the choir highlighted the
importance of cultural exchange and fostering international relations.
Mr. Speaker, I ask all members here to
welcome the University of the Philippines Madrigal Singers and support them in
sharing their talents with us today. Mabuhay.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from
Saskatoon Meewasin.
Mr.
Teed: — Thank you so much, Mr. Speaker. To
you and through you, I’d like to join with the Minister of Parks, Culture and
Sport as the official opposition critic in welcoming these outstanding singers,
outstanding guests to their Legislative Assembly. It is my honour to welcome
the University of the Philippines Madrigal Singers on their national tour
through Canada.
Mr. Speaker, it was something to listen
to, echoing through our marble halls this afternoon. I was able to take a quick
peek in and listen to . . . it sounded like maybe an African-themed
program that you were singing through. It was just amazing. Mr. Speaker, this
is just such an exemplary example of talent. I just want to say thank you so
much for choosing to make our legislature a stop on your visit.
And I just want to, while I’m on my
feet, just acknowledge the deep ties between the Philippines and Saskatchewan
and the amazing contribution that the people of the Philippines have brought to
our beautiful province, making our province a more rich and vibrant place.
And so, Mr. Speaker, I would ask all
members to join me on behalf of the official opposition in welcoming these
talented singers to our Legislative Assembly, and theirs for the day here
today.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Justice
and Attorney General.
Hon.
Ms. Eyre: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Leave for an
extended introduction.
The
Speaker: — The minister asked for an extended
introduction. Is leave granted?
Some
Hon. Members: — Agreed.
The
Speaker: — Carried.
Hon.
Ms. Eyre: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Our
government has proclaimed April 28th to May 4th Missing Persons Week here in
Saskatchewan. It’s hosted every year by the Saskatchewan Missing Persons
Partnership, which is unique to the province. It includes community-based
Indigenous organizations along with police agencies and government ministries.
Its goal, Mr. Speaker, to honour more than 140 long-term missing in the
province and to raise awareness about missing persons’ cases and issues.
This year’s theme is Stories, not
Statistics, which reminds us that Saskatchewan’s missing persons are loved.
They are deeply missed by their families and friends who continue to search for
them in the hope that they will one day be able to bring them home.
Mr. Speaker, we have several of these
devoted family members with us in the gallery this afternoon and I would like
to welcome them, Mr. Speaker. I had the honour of meeting some of them at the
announcement this morning before the second annual Walk to Honour the Missing.
And I would like to thank all the families for sharing their loved ones’
poignant stories through the beautiful memory boxes that they created yesterday
before the candlelight vigil in Wascana Park.
Today’s Walk to Honour the Missing and
last night’s vigil, Mr. Speaker, were attended by the families, as well as
members of the public, organizations that support families and investigate
cases of missing persons. Several of my colleagues were there, Mr. Speaker, as
well as His Honour the Lieutenant Governor of Saskatchewan. A full list of
events can be found on the Saskatchewan Missing Persons Partnership’s Facebook
page and on the government’s website, saskatchewan.ca, under help for missing
persons.
Mr. Speaker, please join me in welcoming
these families to this, their Legislative Assembly.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from
Saskatoon Centre.
Ms.
Nippi-Albright: — Miigwech, Mr. Speaker. I also would
like to join the minister in welcoming the families of missing persons. First
of all, I just want to say:
[The hon. member spoke for a time in
Saulteaux.]
I just want to say thank you for coming
here to join today. I’ve seen, known a lot of you out there that have had loved
ones gone missing and/or murdered. So I just want you to know that here the
official opposition, we are thinking about you. We are praying and we’re also
praying for those that are still missing, that we want them to come home so
that families have closure. So gichi-miigwech.
[The hon. member spoke for a time in
Saulteaux.]
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Crown
Investments Corporation.
Hon.
Mr. Duncan: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker,
seated in the west gallery we’re joined by members of the Crown Investments
Corporation Advisory Council on Indigenous Reconciliation, also known as ACIR.
The advisory council is comprised of Indigenous engagement subject matter
experts from across the Crown sector and government ministries, and the council
enhances the work of government in advancing prosperity and economic
reconciliation.
The council’s work is focused on four
main areas: training and development, recruitment and retention, business
development and procurement, and community investment, all with the objective
of meeting the Truth and Reconciliation Commission’s Call to Action no. 57
and 92.
Joining us in the gallery this afternoon
is Dawn Anaquod, Wavell Starr, Joanne Johnson, Jennifer Matts, Joseph Daniels —
who by the way, Mr. Speaker, did an excellent job of emceeing a very important
event yesterday between the signing of an MOU [memorandum of understanding]
between SaskEnergy and the First Nations Power Authority — Dana Soonias,
Courtney Mihalicz, Julie Ann Wriston, John Lax, and Darcy Tourangeau.
Mr. Speaker, as well there’s a few
members of the ACIR committee who could not be here today, but I wanted to put
their names in the record as well for the great work that they are doing: Fawn
Redwood, Tara Gereaux, Alethea Foster, Marmie Poitras, Kyle Bateson, Daryl
Bunnell, Matt Smith, Shelley Thomas Prokop, and Cherish Jean-Baptiste.
Mr. Speaker, I’d ask all members to join
with me in welcoming the members of the advisory council to their Legislative
Assembly.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from
Saskatoon Centre.
Ms.
Nippi-Albright: — Miigwech, Mr. Speaker. I also would
like to join the minister in welcoming these guests to their legislature. It’s
always wonderful to hear that there are Indigenous people that are working
towards and advancing reconciliation in this province, and as the critic for
First Nations and Métis relations and truth and reconciliation, it’s important
to see the good work that’s being done and led by strong Indigenous leaders.
And I just want to say thank for your
public service and the leadership you bring, and especially when it comes to
truth and reconciliation. Miigwech.
[The hon. member spoke for a time in
Saulteaux.]
Thanks.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Finance.
Hon.
Ms. Harpauer: — It’s an honour to introduce 26
fabulous grade 12 students from Humboldt Collegiate in Humboldt. And they are
accompanied by two teachers, Mr. Millette and Mr. Rowe. Both teachers have been
here a number of times, so it’s great to see them again with another great
grade 12 classroom.
So I ask all members to join me in
welcoming these fabulous students to their Legislative Assembly.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Coronation Park.
Mr.
Burki: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It’s my
pleasure to welcome the group that came from all the way from Philippines,
University of the Philippines, madrigal music that they are doing over here,
and they are on the tour of Canada. They will be travelling to other provinces
as well, but I will welcome over here to the legislature.
And just to let you know that Filipino
is one of the biggest community and growing community in every sector — in our
health care, in education, in our hospitality. And we wish to make sure it
grows the same way. And we have a special connection with them as well. So I
will ask and request all members to join me and to welcome this group to their
Legislative Assembly.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Rosemont.
Mr.
Wotherspoon: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And to you
and through you, it’s wonderful to have everyone that’s here today, but I’d be
remiss not to welcome Elder Lorna Standingready, seated in the east gallery,
Mr. Speaker, looking upon us here today.
This is someone who has led in this
province, in our community for so many years. She’s always fought for justice
and truth and reconciliation, long before those words were ever spoken in that
way. She’s a minister within the community. She’s a matriarch within the
community. She’s someone that I’ve relied upon as a teacher. She’s a survivor
of residential schools, Mr. Speaker, and somebody that day in, day out makes this
community and this province a better place. So I ask all members of this
Assembly to join with me in welcoming Elder Lorna Standingready.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from
Saskatoon Meewasin.
Mr.
Teed: — Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker.
It’s an honour to be on my feet presenting our petition calling on the
government to reverse the ban on third-party sex ed providers in our public
schools.
Mr. Speaker, the undersigned residents
of the province of Saskatchewan wish to bring to our attention the following:
banning third-party providers of sexual health education will mean fewer kids
getting access to evidence-based sex education, which we need desperately in
Saskatchewan given that we have the highest rates of teen pregnancy, STIs
[sexually transmitted infection] and HIV [human immunodeficiency virus]
transmission in the country.
We also have the highest rates of sexual
assault and domestic violence in the country. Banning third-party sexual health
education has a broader reach as this ban impacts additional prevention
education programs, programs focused on body safety, consent, and healthy
relationships. Mr. Speaker, all children have the right to a comprehensive,
age-appropriate sexual health education.
I will read the prayer:
We, in the prayer
that reads as follows, respectfully request that the Legislative Assembly of
Saskatchewan call on the Government of Saskatchewan to immediately reverse its
policy decision to ban third-party sexual health educators in Saskatchewan
schools and to listen to experts and stakeholders in developing comprehensive
sex education curriculum for all of our publicly funded schools.
Mr. Speaker, the undersigned reside in
Regina. I do so submit.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Arm
River.
Mr.
Skoropad: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker,
[13:45]
I will read the prayer:
We, in the prayer
that reads as follows, respectfully request that the Legislative Assembly of
Saskatchewan take the following action: to call upon the Government of Canada
to immediately suspend the carbon tax across the nation of Canada and
acknowledge its significant impact on affordability and inflation in Canada.
Below, the
undersigned are residents of Yorkton and Saskatoon. I so present.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
University.
Ms.
A. Young: — Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker.
It’s a privilege to rise again today and present a petition to this legislature
calling for the funding of IVF [in vitro fertilization] treatments, Mr.
Speaker.
You know, today I’m presenting this
petition. I’ll try and be inclusive, talk about all the different people that
this impacts: really impacts queer communities, impacts single people, and I
want to talk today about the impact that this has on women in particular, Mr.
Speaker.
This petition is calling for the funding
of in vitro fertilization treatments for fertility care, Mr. Speaker, but
before people can get to the point of being approved to even pursue this, there
is often, as per policy requirement, two years of struggles with fertility. Mr.
Speaker, two years of struggling to conceive, often with women being told they
must have three consecutive miscarriages before they will be permitted to
testing to investigate the root causes.
Mr. Speaker, this is a horrific
situation for anyone to find themselves in, certainly when it comes to mental
health, when it comes to their experiences as an individual trying to navigate
the health care system, Mr. Speaker. The toll that this takes on families is
not just financial, but is emotional and is a significant contributor to
declining mental health amongst people struggling.
I’ll read the prayer:
We, in the prayer
that reads as follows, respectfully request that the Government of Saskatchewan
immediately move to cover the financial burden of two rounds of IVF treatment
for Saskatchewan people experiencing infertility.
The signatories of this petition today,
Mr. Speaker, reside in Weyburn. I do so present.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Walsh Acres.
Mr. Clarke:
— Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise today to present a petition calling for
adequate funding for education. Mr. Speaker, this is something I’ve talked
about as a former educator, grade 6/7 teacher for the last eight years in
Regina. Saw every day the impacts that the Sask Party’s cuts to education have
meant for students — whether you’re an EAL [English as an additional language]
student who comes to this province as an immigrant knowing no English and being
plopped into a school without any supports besides the classroom teacher; or a
young child, a kindergarten student who doesn’t have access to speech pathology
and isn’t able to develop and have their speech be supported and their growth
there continue in a good way.
There’s a lot, a lot of issues in
Saskatchewan schools. And I hope this government is listening to teachers when
they say class size and complexity matters, and they need support from this
government to improve that for Saskatchewan kids, for Saskatchewan’s future.
I’ll read the prayer:
We, in the prayer that reads as follows, respectfully request that the
Legislative Assembly of Saskatchewan call on the Government of Saskatchewan to
provide adequate, sustainable, and predictable operating funds for our 27
public and separate school divisions to ensure that schools, teachers, and
other caring professionals are able to meet the needs of every student in
Saskatchewan.
Mr. Speaker, the residents of today’s
petition reside in Regina. I do so present.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Douglas Park.
Ms.
Sarauer: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise yet
again today to present another petition calling for the government to improve
labour laws in Saskatchewan. Those who have signed this petition wish to bring
to our attention the following: that even after the October 1st increase to
minimum wage, Saskatchewan’s minimum wage remains the lowest in the country.
Mr. Speaker, in addition the official opposition has twice introduced paid sick
leave legislation since the onset of the pandemic, and it is well known now that
paid sick leave has been proven to save employers money while making workplaces
healthier and safer for workers.
Mr. Speaker, it’s very unfortunate to
say that 71 per cent of workers in Canada have experienced workplace violence
and/or harassment. Mr. Speaker, I just heard from yet another person this
morning in my office who disclosed a harassment situation in her workplace. Mr.
Speaker, this happens way too often in Saskatchewan. The government should do
much more than they do to ensure that workplaces are harassment free in this
province.
I’d like to read the prayer:
We, in the prayer
that reads as follows, respectfully request the Legislative Assembly of
Saskatchewan call on the Government of Saskatchewan to improve conditions for
Saskatchewan workers by passing legislation to increase the minimum wage,
guarantee paid sick leave, limit nondisclosure agreements which could silence
survivors of workplace harassment, and require employers to track and report
incidents of violence and harassment in the workplace.
All provisions which exist in our
private member’s bill, Bill 613. We do hope the government passes that
legislation.
Mr. Speaker, those who have signed this
petition come from Canwood, Leoville, and Spiritwood. I do present.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Elphinstone-Centre.
Ms.
Conway: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This
petition is calling on the government to remove lead waterlines in Regina. The
province of Saskatchewan is responsible for ensuring that the people of
Saskatchewan get safe drinking water, but many citizens here in Regina do not
have safe drinking water because the pipes that deliver that water, the water
to their homes, are both made of lead and they’re quite old, resulting in high
concentrations of lead leaching into their drinking water.
This situation has unequal impacts on
the health of vulnerable people, including children, low-income residents,
Indigenous people, seniors, renters, and new Canadians living in Regina’s core
neighbourhoods. The province of Saskatchewan administers federal infrastructure
dollars that is intended for revitalizing core infrastructure, including safe
drinking water.
The signatories are
calling on the Government of Saskatchewan to ensure access to safe drinking
water for all Regina residents by providing supports to the city of Regina to
replace lead water mains quickly and safely.
The signatories reside in Regina. I do
so present.
The Speaker:
— I recognize the member from Saskatoon Eastview.
Mr.
Love: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise today
to recognize the incredible work of the Persephone Theatre in Saskatoon for its
youth-focused acting program, Young Company. This is a unique blend of
classroom and theatre for teens aged 14 to 19 who aspire to find a career in
the performing arts.
This past winter I had the privilege of
attending The Trials, a performance that showcased the young performers’
immense talent and dedication under the guidance of instructor Kristi Friday. The
Trials presents a near-dystopian future triggered by the climate crisis,
positioning youth as jurors in a trial to hold previous generations responsible
for the state of the planet.
Mr. Speaker, we know the youth bear a
disproportionate burden when it comes to climate change. Their perspectives are
crucial, yet often under-represented in discussions on climate action. The
Trials gave these youth a meaningful platform to engage deeply with their
audience on a discussion that is so important.
I want to thank Young Company for
reminding me about the vital role that the arts play in bringing forward
positive change and for helping all of us to move towards a more sustainable
future. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Melfort.
Mr.
Goudy: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I was
touched and humbled today to join with the Minister of Justice, the Minister of
Social Services, and several colleagues to take part in the proclamation
announcement as part of Missing Persons Week in Saskatchewan, April 28th to May
4th.
Mr. Speaker, for the past 11 years the
Government of Saskatchewan has proclaimed this week with the Saskatchewan
Missing Persons Partnership to raise awareness about missing persons cases and
trying to help others from experiencing the same tragedy. Long-term missing
persons are those who have been missing for more than six months.
And, Mr. Speaker, to sit at the table
with families who have lost loved ones, it was heartbreaking to say the least.
And you know, to see that there’s many organizations in our province who are
pulling together and working together with these families and raising awareness
and trying to figure out ways of putting together policies and procedures and
legislation that can help us make sure that this doesn’t happen moving forward.
So, Mr. Speaker, I’d like to thank the
families for being here today and sharing their loved ones’ stories with us. I
hope that events such as last night’s candlelight vigil and today’s walk
provide some measure of comfort as you bear such an ongoing and overwhelming
burden. And please know that everyone in this Chamber, on the government and
opposition side, that many of us are parents and grandparents, and our hearts
are truly with you. Thank you.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Coronation Park.
Mr.
Burki: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise today
to recognize Coronation Park Community School. The staff at this school show
incredible dedication to their students, both in the classroom and outside.
They go the extra mile to truly show they care.
One of these ways is through their
annual holiday lunch. I had the honour to attend and serve food at their event
on the 14th of December. The food was also served by volunteers in the
community from the Regina Police Service and from the Regina fire department.
It was inspiring to see how much the staff at Regina Coronation school care
about the well-being of their students, and it was wonderful to see how much
joy the meal brought to all the kids.
Once again, Saskatchewan teachers and
school staff have stepped up to the plate to take care of their students. I’m
so proud to be able to say that we share a community. I invite all members to
join me in thanking the teachers and the staff at Regina Coronation school for
the dedication that they have for their students. Thank you.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from
Lumsden-Morse.
Mr.
B. McLeod: — Mr. Speaker, I rise today to extend
a warm welcome on behalf of our government to the Philippine Madrigal Singers,
known as Madz, and their delegation who are visiting our province as part of
their intense 60‑concert tour. Recognized by UNESCO [United Nations
Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization] as artists for peace, Madz
are ambassadors of Philippine culture and good will, and are one of the most
awarded choral groups in the world.
The choir’s week-long visit to
Saskatchewan began on Friday, April 26 and will end on Friday, May the 3rd.
Madz had a busy week planned that included hosting choral workshops, three
concerts — all sold out — fundraising for the Regina community, and touring the
area. Mr. Speaker, last night I had the pleasure of attending their concert in
my constituency at the historic St. Andrew’s United Church in Lumsden —
beautiful facility and the acoustics were amazing.
Mr. Speaker, 2024 also marks the 75th
anniversary celebration of the Philippines-Canada friendship, which makes the
Philippine Madrigal Singers’ visit even more special. Over the years the
Philippines has become an important trading partner across Canada, and here in
Saskatchewan we are proud to have a strong and growing Filipino community who
have contributed greatly to our province’s economy and rich cultural fabric.
I’d like to again thank Madz for being
here today as we are proud to celebrate this anniversary together. Thank you
for your presence in our legislature today. And to your friends and hosts,
thank you for bringing your friends to this your legislature.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from
Saskatoon Southeast.
Hon.
Mr. Morgan: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise today
to highlight the important work of the CIC [Crown Investments Corporation of
Saskatchewan] Advisory Council on Indigenous Reconciliation, or ACIR. This
advisory council originated from the ongoing Crown collaboration initiative
with a mandate to enhance the Government of Saskatchewan’s endeavours towards
economic reconciliation.
Comprised of representatives from across
the Crowns and key government entities, the council is committed to sharing
knowledge and providing direction towards fostering economic, social, and
cultural prosperity among the Indigenous peoples, ensuring their success across
Saskatchewan.
Mr. Speaker, some notable
accomplishments in the council’s short tenure include the launch of the Crown
Career Pathways Indigenous internship program in October of 2023 and the
inaugural Indigenous Employee Networks Conference held this past March. With
specific attention to training and development, recruitment and retention,
community investment, and Indigenous business development and procurement, the
council is poised to make tangible, lasting differences in the lives of
Indigenous peoples and advance meaningful reconciliation.
Mr. Speaker, I invite all members of
this Assembly to join me in commending the ongoing efforts of the CIC Advisory
Council on Indigenous Reconciliation and thank them for the work in paving the
way towards a more prosperous future for all in Saskatchewan. Thank you, Mr.
Speaker.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from
Martensville-Warman.
Mr.
Jenson: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Yesterday I
joined the Minister of Trade and Export Development and several Indigenous
business leaders at the English River First Nation Business Complex for an
exciting announcement.
The province is investing $400,000 as
part of a new partnership with the Saskatchewan First Nations Natural Resource
Centre of Excellence. This investment will be used to conduct a needs
assessment which will identify barriers faced by Indigenous peoples when trying
to enter employment in the natural resources sector. The assessment will be
used to develop strategies to connect Indigenous people to jobs in the natural
resource sectors.
[14:00]
I’d like to read some comments from our
partners into the record, Mr. Speaker. From Sheldon Wuttunee, president and CEO
[chief executive officer] of the First Nations Natural Resource Centre of
Excellence: “We want our kids to be well-prepared and want them to participate
and build values for the future. Partnerships like this we are announcing today
are extremely important to us.”
From Chief Delbert Wapass of
Thunderchild First Nation: “The Saskatchewan Party has done so much to help
Saskatchewan’s Indigenous people.”
Sean Willy, president and CEO of the Des
Nedhe Group, said, “This is another groundbreaking partnership created in
Saskatchewan.”
And finally, Mr. Speaker, from Tyson
Bear, Chief of Flying Dust First Nation: “By working together, we will grow
together for a better future for all of us in Saskatchewan.”
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Yorkton.
Mr.
Ottenbreit: — Mr. Speaker, the NDP like to rage
against lobbyists. They like to rage against out-of-province political
donations, and they like to rage against corporate donations. But when it comes
to sell $200 tickets or $2,500 sponsorships to the NDP leader’s cocktail
reception, who do they ask? Out-of-province, corporate lobby firms.
The NDP leader claims she says the same
thing in every room. She says she opposes the Trudeau carbon tax, but then she
goes to the Trudeau campaign school. They accuse our minister wrongly of not
talking to reporters after question period. Then the NDP leader ducks reporters
after question period.
And they say they won’t take
out-of-province, corporate donations from lobbyists, then they send out
fundraising emails to their leader’s cocktail reception to out-of-province,
corporate lobbyists.
Say one thing, do another. That’s the
NDP, Mr. Speaker.
The
Speaker: — I
recognize the Leader of the Opposition.
Ms.
Beck: — Mr. Speaker, this tired and
out-of-touch and increasingly desperate government is failing to deliver the
cost-of-living relief that Saskatchewan people need and deserve, with 57 per
cent of people in this province struggling to pay the grocery bill. But it’s no
wonder when we see that under that Premier’s watch, families are bringing home
less while the cost of everything is rising.
Why won’t the Premier act and finally
offer Saskatchewan people some relief and suspend the fuel tax?
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Premier.
Hon.
Mr. Moe: — Once again on the floor of this
Assembly, Mr. Speaker, I would say that in this most recent budget that was
introduced — and I suspect is going to be passed in the days ahead — we were
able to preserve over $2 billion worth of affordability measures for
Saskatchewan people and Saskatchewan families. It’s in those affordability
measures that we are able to say that Saskatchewan is one of the most
affordable, if not the most affordable place to live in the nation of Canada,
Mr. Speaker.
There is no doubt that we are facing
affordability challenges across this nation, I would say largely put on the
people of this nation by the federal coalition government and the introduction
and the ever-increasing, annually increasing carbon tax that they have put on
the backs of all Canadian families. It’s pushing up the price of the fuel when
families and mothers are going to the gas pumps to fill up their vehicles to
take their children to sports and to school. Mr. Speaker, it’s put on the price
of the groceries that we see each and every day when we go to the grocery store
in whatever community across this nation we might have.
And it’s a tax that has largely been
supported not only by the federal NDP but by their brothers and sisters here in
Saskatchewan, their provincial arm of their party, Mr. Speaker, to the degree
that there are members in the provincial NDP that have found their way to
Ottawa to attend a Trudeau campaign school. These folks definitely are
Trudeau’s choice in the province of Saskatchewan, Mr. Speaker. They just may
not be Saskatchewan people’s choice.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Leader of the
Opposition.
Ms.
Beck: — Mr. Speaker, whether the Premier
understands it or not, Saskatchewan people are struggling. And Saskatchewan
people are struggling because this Premier keeps selling out Saskatchewan jobs.
Mr. Speaker, the Sask Party’s plan isn’t for Saskatchewan jobs. No, it’s
literally a plan for jobs anywhere else but Saskatchewan.
Now, Mr. Speaker, he doesn’t have to
take my word for it. Statistics Canada yesterday released new data, new data
that shows that after the last 12 months in this province we’ve lost another
91, 91 Saskatchewan businesses. That’s 91 fewer businesses hiring local people
and fewer businesses benefiting local communities.
Mr. Speaker, why won’t this Premier stop
selling out Saskatchewan jobs and hire Saskatchewan?
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Premier.
Hon.
Mr. Moe: — Mr. Speaker, the most recent reports
from Statistics Canada have Saskatchewan jobs up ten and a half thousand over
the course of the last year. What that has precipitated, Mr. Speaker, is 30,000
more people living in Saskatchewan communities, people coming from all over,
all around the world, making their home in a Saskatchewan community.
Mr. Speaker, we have 225 individuals
that have brought their families, are working in a Saskatchewan Health
Authority complex in a community across Saskatchewan. Many of them largely are
recruited from the Philippines.
We have people that are working in the
potash industry, Mr. Speaker, due to — another statistic from Statistics Canada
— Saskatchewan last year was second in attracting private sector investment
into our province, into our communities, private sector investment that is
employing many of those ten and a half thousand people, Mr. Speaker. And
Statistics Canada also says that we’re set to lead the nation when it comes to
private sector capital investment in the nation of Canada this year.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Leader of the
Opposition.
Ms.
Beck: — Saskatchewan people can’t pay their
bills, businesses are closing, but this Premier is clapping for himself as are
his minions, Mr. Speaker. Saskatchewan people, they don’t care about spin,
increasingly desperate spin, Mr. Speaker. Saskatchewan people care about
results.
And the results are in. Over the last
year, 8 businesses closed in Regina, 30 were lost in Saskatoon, Mr. Speaker,
and 53 businesses were closed everywhere else in the province. That means that
there are 91 fewer businesses than there were 12 months ago.
Mr. Speaker, to the Premier: how is that
growth that works for everyone?
The
Speaker: — I’d just like to caution the Leader
of the Opposition on her choice of words. I recognize the Minister of Crown
Investments Corporation.
Hon.
Mr. Duncan: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Through our
Crown corporations alone we’re going to spend $2.6 billion in this
province in the upcoming year on capital, Mr. Speaker.
We’re going to extend fibre across this
province, Mr. Speaker. In fact the budget of the Crown corporations in terms of
capital under the last NDP government in the last year, Mr. Speaker, doesn’t
even equate what SaskTel is going to spend in capital in this province.
And, Mr. Speaker, when you look at the
record, how many Saskatchewan jobs were created when $16 million were lost
under the NDP on a Chicago-based fibre optics company? Zero. How many jobs were
created in Saskatchewan when $9.4 million was lost on a Newfoundland cable
company? Zero. How many jobs were created in Saskatchewan when $25 million
was lost on an Atlanta, Georgia-based dot-com company? Zero, Mr. Speaker.
That’s the record of the NDP.
On the record on this side of this
House, we’re growing jobs; we’re growing this economy, Mr. Speaker.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Leader of the
Opposition.
Ms.
Beck: — Mr. Speaker, not only do we have a
premier who’s not standing up for Saskatchewan jobs, he won’t even stand up and
answer his own questions. Now this is a premier who is failing. He’s failing
when it comes to the cost of living, he’s failing when it comes to jobs, and
he’s failing when it comes to our kids’ classrooms.
The Education minister asked school
board trustees to use their voice and speak up about the Sask Party’s record on
education. Well, Mr. Speaker, here’s what Saskatoon Public had to say, and I
quote:
This increase will
not come close to addressing the significant increase in student need. There’s
not enough money in this budget to decrease average class size or adequately
address the issue of classroom complexity.
So, Mr. Speaker, why is the Premier
choosing not to invest in our kids’ classrooms?
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of
Education.
Hon.
Mr. Cockrill: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. You know,
I’ll remind the Leader of the Opposition that this budget saw the largest ever
school operating funding increase in provincial history. For Saskatoon Public
alone — and I’ve shared these numbers yesterday; I’ll share the numbers again —
Saskatoon Public will receive $286 million to their school operating
grant, an increase of 26.7 million or 10.3 per cent year over year, Mr.
Speaker.
This is a government that is investing
in education, is continuing to do so. But, Mr. Speaker, that’s a leader of the
opposition that said that she would put class size and complexity in the
contract, which would undermine the role of school boards, one of whom she used
to sit on. Thank you.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Leader of the
Opposition.
Ms.
Beck: — Mr. Speaker, I will remind the
minister that it is because of the record of that government that no one in
this province trusts them when it comes to education.
Now, Mr. Speaker, to the minister I’ll
say this: be careful what you wish for. Because this minister, who asked school
divisions to speak up, should listen to what school divisions have to say. And
I quote: “In 2016‑2017 high school enrolment was 8,558 students with 520
teachers. In 2023‑24 high school enrolment is 9,031 students with 480
teachers.” Mr. Speaker, that’s 473 more students with 40 fewer teachers.
How does the Premier, the minister, how
do any of them defend that record?
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of
Education.
Hon.
Mr. Cockrill: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. You know, to
keep the discussion specific on Saskatoon Public, since 2018 enrolment in
Saskatoon Public has gone up 16 per cent, but operating funding has gone up 24
per cent since that time, Mr. Speaker.
In this budget alone, as I said, Mr.
Speaker, we’re seeing a double-digit percentage increase to the funding to
Saskatoon Public, not to mention two new joint-use schools for four new schools
being built in Saskatoon in future years to address the enrolment growth that
we’re seeing and really the challenges of growth that we see in our province,
which we didn’t see under the NDP.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from
Saskatoon Eastview.
Mr.
Love: — Mr. Speaker, this minister’s short
record on education is not one to be proud of, and he should have been fired
long ago. Under this tired and out-of-touch government’s watch, they’ve hired
just one new classroom teacher while adding 15,000 new students province-wide.
And the reality, the reality in Saskatoon Public Schools is that they’ve added
473 more high school students with 40 fewer teachers there.
Now when I asked the minister in
committee if this government’s record of underfunding would cause more cuts, he
said I was ridiculous. Does the minister think Saskatoon Public School Board is
ridiculous too?
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of
Education.
Hon.
Mr. Cockrill: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I will
remind the member opposite again, Saskatoon Public is going to see a 10.3 per
cent year-over-year funding increase. With that funding, they’re going to be
able to offer more supports for students, hire more EAs [educational
assistant], more teachers, Mr. Speaker. We’ll continue to work with Saskatoon
Public and every school board in this province. Thank you.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from
Saskatoon Eastview.
Mr.
Love: — And I’ll remind that failing
minister, it’s not just Saskatoon Public speaking out. It’s other divisions
too. Yesterday, Greater Saskatoon Catholic Schools added their voice:
This announcement
is a good first step, but we require years of additional investments in
education to reduce the funding gap and return to service offerings that were
reduced in 2016‑17.
That is their record, Mr. Speaker. Both
divisions in our largest city are speaking out about this tired and
out-of-touch government’s failure to properly support our kids and their classrooms.
Does the minister honestly believe that he’s got it right and both divisions in
our province’s largest city have it wrong?
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of
Education.
Hon.
Mr. Cockrill: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I thank the
member opposite for the question and bringing up Saskatoon Catholic, because
while the funding increase year over year was 10.3 per cent for Saskatoon
Public, the year-over-year percentage increase for Saskatoon Catholic was 14
per cent. Again, since 2018 enrolment has increased 21 per cent in Greater
Saskatoon Catholic Schools, and the operating funding has gone up 32 per cent
in that same time frame, Mr. Speaker.
Again, Mr. Speaker, this budget has the
largest school operating funding increase that this province has ever seen. The
member won’t even stop to listen to my question . . . listen to the
answer to his question, pardon me, Mr. Speaker. If he would, he’d hear about
our record investments into education. Thank you.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Elphinstone-Centre.
Ms.
Conway: — Or to summarize the minister’s
answer, what are they complaining about, Mr. Speaker?
An
Hon. Member: — They should be grateful.
Ms.
Conway: — They should be grateful. Exactly.
Mr. Speaker, earlier this morning the
leadership of Shercom held a press conference. That’s the Saskatoon-based
company that had the tire recycling contract before this government handed it
to a company from Newport Beach, California. In the press conference, they
raised a number of concerns about this government’s oversight of tire recycling
in this province. They claimed that they met with the Premier back in 2016 and
were assured that there would be “no changes to their ability to operate in
Saskatchewan.”
Did the
Premier make that promise? And if so, why did he break it?
The Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of
Environment.
[14:15]
Hon. Ms. Tell: — Mr. Speaker, as I said a few times
here in the past number of days, Tire Stewardship of Saskatchewan is an
industry-based organization that manages tire recycling in the province. They
are awarded delegated responsibility. TSS [Tire Stewardship of Saskatchewan] is
provided delegated responsibility, and what TSS has done is conduct an open and
transparent RFP [request for proposal] process for a processor in southern
Saskatchewan. The ministry’s role is one of oversight to ensure that all
commitments are fulfilled under the scrap tire recycling program, Mr. Speaker.
The
Premier indicated earlier that Shercom did not bid on the contract that we were
speaking about in the South. He also thought there may have been only one
bidder, not that there was only one bidder, Mr. Speaker . . .
The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Elphinstone-Centre.
Ms. Conway: — Mr. Speaker, the minister is not
even in the stratosphere of my question. She is reading tired talking points
that she’s read out here day after day. So I’ll ask the question again.
The
question was about and to the Premier, who Shercom says made assurances to them
back in 2016. Did he make those promises? And if so, why did he break them?
The Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of
Environment.
Hon. Ms. Tell: — Yeah, thank you, Mr. Speaker. The
relationship between Shercom and TSS is between Shercom and TSS. TSS operates
independent of government in an industry-led board that addresses and ensures
that the scrap tire recycling is conducted in the province of Saskatchewan.
That hasn’t changed from three years ago to now, Mr. Speaker. It remains the
same. Thank you.
The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Elphinstone-Centre.
Ms. Conway: — Mr. Speaker, the question was about
2016, a time period that TSS didn’t even exist, news flash to the minister.
It’s no small thing to receive a promise from a minister and then have it
broken. That’s why they say — this is Shercom and I quote — that they were
“stabbed in the back in our own backyard.”
Government
contracts need to be open. They need to be transparent. And that’s not what we
have seen with this deal. Why did the Sask Party send out an RFP for this
lucrative tire contract that excluded the Saskatoon-based company already doing
the work?
The Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of
Environment.
Hon. Ms. Tell: — Mr. Speaker, the RFP for the
southern processor was issued by TSS. The government had no involvement at all
in that particular process. That was done solely by TSS, Mr. Speaker. Thank
you.
The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Elphinstone-Centre.
Ms. Conway: — Mr. Speaker, they also raise
concerns about value-add jobs being sent out of province. They say that the
high-value, value-added processing that they used to do in Saskatoon isn’t
being done by the company from Newport Beach, California. They say that tires
are now being shipped out of province without actually being fully processed
here in Saskatchewan. Now their company has to order product from outside
Saskatchewan. In their words, “None of this makes any sense.”
So
to the minister: what is your response to that?
The Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of
Environment.
Hon. Ms. Tell: — Mr. Speaker, the relationship
between the tire processors in the province is between TSS and the related tire
processors.
An
RFP was issued for the southern processor by TSS. Obviously we have CRM [Crumb
Rubber Manufacturers], who was awarded the contract for the southern half of
the province, Mr. Speaker. And again that relationship is between CRM and TSS.
The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Elphinstone-Centre.
Ms. Conway: — Mr. Speaker, I’ll quote from the
submission to the minister that was required in order to get approval for TSS
to exist: “The minister is ultimately responsible and accountable for an
effective program in Saskatchewan.”
TSS
reports to her quarterly, Mr. Speaker. I understand she doesn’t want to touch
this file. She doesn’t want to touch the questions, and I understand why. Who
would want to be responsible for this tire fire of a deal? But she’s the
Minister of Environment. She’s the one who’s accountable. She’s the one who’s
responsible. And she should be prepared to answer basic questions here in this
Assembly.
Yesterday
the CEO of the Saskatoon chamber of commerce wrote to her with a series of
requests to improve transparency and get this back on track. Will she be taking
them up on any of their ideas?
The Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of
Environment.
Hon. Ms. Tell: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. With respect
to the oversight provided by the ministry, and I will repeat this each and
every time she brings it up, the Ministry of Environment’s role is one of
oversight to ensure that all commitments — not the day-to-day operation of TSS
— are fulfilled under scrap tire recycling program.
With
respect to the letter written by the chamber of commerce in Saskatoon, we will
be responding to those in due course. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Elphinstone-Centre.
Ms. Conway: — Didn’t touch the question, Mr.
Speaker. I’ll quote here from the TSS governance structure in their own annual
report about the Minister of Environment. She sets the mandate and legislation.
She sets the regulations. She approves the program, and she ensures compliance,
Mr. Speaker.
So
again the Saskatoon chamber asked the minister to release the reports that
apparently justify this entire fiasco. So far, she has refused. But guess what?
She’s the one with the power to release these documents. That’s what the
chamber is asking for, that’s what we’ve asked for, and that’s what the
Saskatoon company that was already doing the work has asked for.
Sunlight
is the best disinfectant, Mr. Speaker. Why won’t the minister release those
reports today?
The Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of
Environment.
Hon. Ms. Tell: — Mr. Speaker, the report the member
opposite, or she, is referencing was shared with the ministry by TSS legal
counsel. This report is not ours to share. Any questions regarding the report
are best answered by Tire Stewardship of Saskatchewan, Mr. Speaker.
The
Proposed Product Stewardship Program for Scrap Tire Management, ’21‑23,
this report the member is referencing is publicly available on the TSS website,
Mr. Speaker.
The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Walsh Acres.
Mr.
Clarke:
— Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It sure must be tough being the least transparent
government in Saskatchewan history. Now that tired and out-of-touch government
has a lot to answer for this tire deal, and they’ve got a lot to answer about
why vulnerable cancer patients are paying to receive treatment at Victoria
Hospital.
Mr.
Speaker, yesterday the minister was quick to blame the SHA [Saskatchewan Health
Authority] when he blamed them yesterday. But news flash to the minister —
another news flash — he’s responsible for the actions of the SHA. Now he did
commit yesterday to raising this cut with SHA leadership.
So
what does the minister have to say? Are vulnerable cancer patients paying for
parking today so that they can receive treatment at Victoria Hospital?
The Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Health.
Hon. Mr. Hindley: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Just to
clarify for the member opposite, the SHA has a CEO and they have a leadership
structure and they have a board, and that’s how the SHA operates. The
Government of Saskatchewan provides funding to the SHA to deliver services, Mr.
Speaker.
On
this particular issue, as I said yesterday, this was a decision by the SHA, Mr.
Speaker. Further to that, parking services are managed by the Saskatchewan
Health Authority. In Regina and Saskatoon, parking has always been paid parking
for cancer patients, Mr. Speaker. Prior to the formation of the SHA, under the
old health region model, different regions, different facilities, different
communities had different policies when it came to parking, and this was a
decision made by the SHA to align those policies.
The Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Walsh Acres.
Mr.
Clarke:
— Mr. Speaker, Saskatchewan people see what’s going on with this tired and
out-of-touch government. They see this government’s mismanagement and misplaced
priorities and the waste. The list is long in health care, Mr. Speaker.
We
could talk about the $70 million just this year on contract nurses, the
millions of dollars being paid to Sask Party donors in Calgary for knee and hip
replacement surgeries and breast cancer care. We could talk the
$240 million on the failed AIMS [administrative information management
system] software, all while cancer patients are forced to pay for parking and
families with sick kids are forced to pay out of pocket to go out of province
to get the care that their kids so desperately need.
Mr.
Speaker, if this isn’t a government that has lost touch with the needs of
Saskatchewan people, I don’t know what is. Will the minister reverse the cuts
and ensure that vulnerable cancer patients get . . . don’t have
to pay for treatment at Victoria Hospital?
The Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Health.
Hon. Mr. Hindley: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The list is
long of investments made by this government, a government that is committed to
its health care system, is grateful for its health care teams, Mr. Speaker.
Recent
successes in terms of the number of doctors and health care workers that have
been hired in this province, Mr. Speaker. In the past 29 months, 118 family
physicians hired, 157 specialists have been hired. Launching a new pilot
project to redirect patients from emergency departments. Fourteen new
physicians started practising in rural Saskatchewan under the SIPPA
[Saskatchewan international physician practice assessment] program.
$2.9 billion since 2007 into health care capital projects in this
province. Sixteen long-term care facilities, five hospitals built, more under
way, Mr. Speaker.
I’ll
tell you what isn’t long. It’s the list of what the ideas that the members
opposite have for health care, Mr. Speaker, aside from closing hospitals,
closing long-term care facilities, firing doctors, firing nurses. That’s their
plan and they know it, Mr. Speaker.
The Speaker: — I recognize the member from
Saskatoon Meewasin.
Mr. Teed: — Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker.
The addictions crisis is devastating families and our communities at alarming
rates. Every month the numbers released from the coroners service are even more
stark than the last, with news that Regina experienced an alarming number of
280 overdoses just in March alone. That’s 100 more overdoses than reported in
the previous months of January and February. This crisis is not getting better,
and a policy change that resulted in a 25 per cent increase in overdose deaths in
Alberta isn’t going to save lives here.
Mr.
Speaker, when will the minister realize he made the wrong decision for
Saskatchewan and change course to save lives?
The Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Mental
Health and Addictions.
Hon. Mr. T. McLeod: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. As I’ve said
many times, the focus of this government is on treatment and recovery, which is
a stark contrast to the NDP government in British Columbia. The member opposite
asks about recognizing the error of their ways. Well let’s look to British
Columbia and the NDP government there, who are now backpedalling and
scrambling, trying to undo the policies that this opposition would have us
implement.
I’m
sorry, Mr. Speaker. We’ll take no lessons from the members opposite. We’ll continue
to focus on treatment and recovery and help individuals who are battling
addiction find a healthy, safe life in recovery. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
The Speaker: — I recognize the Chair of the Standing
Committee on Intergovernmental Affairs and Justice.
Mr. Dennis: — Mr. Speaker, I’m instructed by the
Standing Committee on Intergovernmental Affairs and Justice to report that it
has considered certain estimates and to present the seventh report, which
includes the 2024‑2025 estimates and the 2023‑24 supplementary
estimates no. 2.
I
move:
That the seventh report of the Standing Committee on
Intergovernmental Affairs and Justice now be concurred in.
The Speaker: — It has been moved by the Chair:
That the seventh report of the Standing Committee on
Intergovernmental Affairs and Justice be now concurred in.
Is
the Assembly ready for the question?
Some Hon. Members: — Question.
The Speaker: — Is it the pleasure of the Assembly
to adopt the motion?
Some Hon. Members: — Agreed.
The Speaker: — Carried. I recognize the Government
House Leader.
Hon. Mr. J. Harrison: — Thank you. I move that this House do
now adjourn.
The Speaker: — The Government House Leader has
moved to adjourn the House. Is it the pleasure of the Assembly to adopt the
motion?
Some Hon. Members: — Agreed.
The Speaker: — Carried. This House now stands
adjourned until 1:30 tomorrow.
[The
Assembly adjourned at 14:30.]
Published
under the authority of the Hon. Randy Weekes, Speaker
Disclaimer:
The electronic versions of the Legislative Assembly's documents are provided
for information purposes only. The content of the documents is identical to the
printed record; only the presentation differs unless otherwise noted. The
printed versions are the official record for legal purposes.