CONTENTS
Language Education
Programs to Support Indigenous Success
Saskatchewan Youth
Curlers Compete at Nationals
Student Loan
Forgiveness Program Expanded for Nursing Students
Recognizing Mobile
Crisis Services and Retiring Executive Director
Government Increases
Funding for Saskatchewan Parks
Saskatchewan’s
Population Continues to Grow
Government and
Opposition Positions on Carbon Tax
Government’s Economic
Record and Population Growth
Opposition Requests for
Budget Information
Emergency Hotel Stays
Paid by Social Services
Population Growth and
Government Support for Immigrants
Overdose Deaths and
Treatment for Addictions
Bill No. 156 — The
Tobacco Tax Amendment Act, 2024
Bill No. 157 — The
Income Tax Amendment Act, 2024
Bill No. 158 — The
Saskatchewan Commercial Innovation Incentive (Patent Box) Amendment Act, 2024
MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF
BUDGETARY POLICY (BUDGET DEBATE)
FOURTH
SESSION — TWENTY-NINTH LEGISLATURE
of
the
Legislative Assembly of Saskatchewan
DEBATES
AND PROCEEDINGS
(HANSARD)
N.S. Vol. 65 No. 40A Wednesday,
March 27, 2024, 13:30
[Prayers]
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Crown
Investments Corporation.
Hon.
Mr. Duncan: — Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker.
Mr. Speaker, to you and through you to the members of the Legislative Assembly,
I’m honoured as Minister Responsible for the Public Service Commission to
welcome 20 public service employees who are seated in your gallery this
afternoon.
They’re here to take part in the
parliamentary program for the public service. They’ve had a tour of the
legislature; in fact, I think I ran into them a couple of times already today.
They’ll have briefings presented by various officials from the building, as
well as an opportunity to observe question period. I know I’ll be meeting with
them; I believe a member opposite will be as well.
And these participants are employees
from the ministries of Agriculture, Finance, Government Relations, Immigration
and Career Training, SaskBuilds and Procurement,
Trade and Export Development, and the Legislative Assembly Service.
With that, Mr. Speaker, I’d ask all
members to welcome these public servants to their legislature. And I would
also, on behalf of the government, thank them for the work that they do each
and every day in serving the people of Saskatchewan. And with that I would ask
all members to help me welcome them to their Assembly.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Walsh Acres.
Mr. Clarke:
— Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I’d like to join with the minister and welcome these
fine public employees to their Legislative Assembly today. Thank you for the
work that you do for this province every single day. It matters; it’s
important. And the people of the province are indebted to what you do. So thank
you for that.
I look forward to meeting with you later
this afternoon and answering any questions you have about the life as a member
of the opposition. And hopefully your questions aren’t too hard, but I’m ready.
I’m ready.
So I’d ask all members to join me in
welcoming these participants of this program to their Legislative Assembly.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Trade
and Export Development.
Hon.
Mr. J. Harrison: — Well thank you very much, Mr.
Speaker. It’s my pleasure to acknowledge, welcome, congratulate a long-time
friend, a colleague, a stalwart, and a mentor to many in this building over the
past 17 years. After nearly 40 years of working in government, Elaine Peake is
going to be retiring on Tuesday, April 2nd.
Elaine has lived most of her life in
Regina, Mr. Speaker. She started here, like some of us, in 2007. And in her
tenure here, many of us have had the pleasure to work with Elaine as she has
served a number of ministers, including the previous member for Kindersley,
previous member for Martensville, the member for Weyburn-Big Muddy, the member
for Saskatoon Willowgrove, the member for Estevan,
member for Rosetown, and most recently, the member
for Meadow Lake.
Elaine’s time here has been spent over
many ministries, Mr. Speaker, such as Energy and Resources, Central Services, SaskBuilds and Procurement, and not that I have any bias,
Mr. Speaker, but I know her favourite, Trade and Export Development and
Immigration and Career Training.
And among the one thing that has
followed Elaine to all of those ministries has been her famous red mug, Mr.
Speaker. And as much as Elaine has become a staple in this building, so has her
mother, and staff often come to check in on Mom, who will be 94 in December,
Mr. Speaker. And the treats that her mother sends in regularly are going to be
greatly missed.
Elaine looks forward to spending time
with her mother and is looking forward to spending her time travelling in her
retirement, Mr. Speaker. With deep sincerity, thank you, Elaine, for your
service to Saskatchewan, to this Assembly, to this legislature, to the people
of this province. And we wish you the best in your retirement.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Douglas Park.
Ms.
Sarauer: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It’s my
honour to join with the minister in thanking Elaine for her service here. I can
see her, sort of way over on the side there. Thank you so much for all you have
done for the province of Saskatchewan in the work that you have done here in
government. I hope you have, on behalf of the official opposition, a wonderful,
fun-filled, but also restive retirement full of adventure and family.
Just again as we have said with the
other public servants that are here in the gallery today, the life of a public
servant is truly a calling, and we, as citizens of the province, cannot do
enough to say thank you for your work and for your service. So on behalf of the
opposition, we just join with the government in their thanks to you and once
again ask all members to join me in welcoming Elaine to her Assembly.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Walsh Acres.
Mr. Clarke:
— Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It’s my privilege to rise today to introduce Team
Simpson here, Saskatchewan’s under‑18 provincial curling champions of
2023. I’m going to have more to say about them in a member’s statement, but I
do want to give them a shout-out to start.
In the skip position we have Shawna
Simpson — give us a wave, Shawna. And her mom, Gaylene Simpson, today joins us.
Gaylene was the coach. We have Makena Bailey who played second and her dad,
Scott. We have then Lauren Speidel here. We’re missing Katelyn, her sister who
plays lead. Lauren plays third position. And then of course Carla, their mom,
is here as well.
I had the opportunity to chat with Team
Simpson just before we came into the Chamber today. It was a really inspiring
conversation. These young women talked about, you know, working for two years
together as a team with the goal of getting to nationals, to winning
provincials, and then talking about getting to play with their best friends on
their team.
So again I’ll have more to say in my
member’s statement, but I’d ask all members of this Legislative Assembly to
join me in welcoming Team Simpson and their supporting parents here to their
Legislative Assembly.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Parks,
Culture and Sport.
Hon.
Ms. L. Ross: — Well thank you very much, Mr.
Speaker. I’d like to join with the member opposite and welcome this lovely team
to their Legislative Assembly. We just finished watching some absolutely
incredible curling from Team Canada, and Team Canada just doesn’t happen
overnight. It’s teams like this, teams like Team Simpson, that in fact build up
over the years to be successful and will one day represent Canada. So
congratulations on your team building, the work you do, and just, I wish you
all the best in your future. Thank you very much for attending today.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Coronation Park.
Mr.
Burki: — Thank you,
Mr. Speaker. To you and through you, we have two incredible guests over here in
your gallery, John and George. I can’t pronounce their last name in Greek and
they will be very mad at me if I mispronounce. But they’re incredible people
over here, community leaders, supporters, very active in
communities. Recently they have done a fundraising event for Regina hospitals
that was An Evening in Greece. That’s amazing. And we love them. You are
welcome over here to your Legislative Building. And I will ask all members of
this Legislative Assembly to join me welcoming them to their Legislative
Assembly.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Melfort.
Mr.
Goudy: — We, the undersigned residents of the
province of Saskatchewan wish to bring to your attention the following: whereas
the Trudeau Liberal-NDP [New Democratic Party] coalition carbon tax is one of
the main causes of affordability issues and inflation in the nation of Canada;
that the federal Liberal-NDP government was politically motivated in issuing a
carve-out for home heating oil; and that the Government of Saskatchewan’s
decision to not collect or remit the carbon tax on home heating in Saskatchewan
has led to a drop in inflation; further that despite the discussion to not
charge the carbon tax on home heating, Saskatchewan families continue to pay
that tax out of pocket at the pumps, grocery stores, and more.
Therefore:
We, in the prayer
that reads as follows, respectfully request that the Legislative Assembly of
Saskatchewan take the following action: to call upon the Government of Canada
to immediately suspend the carbon tax across the nation of Canada and
acknowledge its significant impact on affordability and inflation in Canada.
The below undersigned are residents of
Yorkton. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I do so submit.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from
Saskatoon Eastview.
Mr.
Love: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It’s my
honour to rise again and present a petition to the Legislative Assembly calling
for adequate funding for education. Now, Mr. Speaker, the folks who signed this
petition know that we’ve seen in this province a decade of falling per-student
funding. We used to be first in the country when it came to providing these
supports for our students, but after this year’s budget we may in fact be in
dead last in per-student funding.
So far during this labour dispute, Mr.
Speaker, it’s been teachers and parents leading the way, raising the alarm at
the state of Saskatchewan classrooms. But yesterday it was students. Hundreds
of them gathered on Taylor Street outside the office of the member from
Saskatoon Southeast raising the alarm on what they see every day in their
classrooms, speaking about class sizes approaching or exceeding 40, talking
about their fellow students who come to school and don’t get the supports that
they need to succeed.
I’ll read the prayer, Mr. Speaker:
We, in the prayer that reads as follows, respectfully request that the
Legislative Assembly of Saskatchewan call on the Government of Saskatchewan to
provide adequate, sustainable, and predictable operating funds for our 27
public and separate school divisions to ensure schools, teachers, and other
caring professionals are able to meet the needs of every student in
Saskatchewan.
Today’s petition is signed by residents
of Beaver Creek, Saskatoon, and Moose Jaw. I do so present.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from
Saskatoon Meewasin.
Mr.
Teed: — Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker.
I’m honoured to be on my feet to present our petition calling on the government
to address the cost-of-living crisis. Mr. Speaker, the number one issue facing
Saskatchewan residents today is the cost-of-living crisis. If you knock doors
in any corner of our province, you’ll meet residents struggling to meet their
basic needs. Worse yet, the ’24‑25 budget has come and gone without a
single new policy or funding allocation to offer relief for Saskatchewan
families.
Mr. Speaker, Saskatchewan has some of
the highest rates of financial instability in the country. Over 50 per cent of
residents polled feel more worse off now than they did one year ago. And more
and more residents are living paycheque to paycheque as the cost of everything
skyrockets. Mr. Speaker, the time to act on cost of living is now, and the
undersigned demand action from their government.
I’ll read the prayer:
We, in the prayer
that reads as follows, respectfully request that the Legislative Assembly of
Saskatchewan call on the Government of Saskatchewan to meaningfully address the
affordability crisis in Saskatchewan.
The undersigned residents reside in
Saskatoon. I do so submit.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Douglas Park.
Ms.
Sarauer: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I rise once
again today to present a petition calling on the government to improve labour
laws in Saskatchewan.
Those who have signed this petition wish
to bring to our attention the following: that after the October 1st increase,
Saskatchewan’s minimum wage continues to be the lowest minimum wage in Canada.
In addition, Mr. Speaker, the official opposition has twice introduced paid
sick leave legislation since the onset of the pandemic. And paid sick leave
legislation, paid sick leave in general, has been proven to save employers
money while making workplaces healthier and safer for all workers.
Mr. Speaker, 71 per cent of workers in
Canada have experienced workplace violence and/or harassment, and much more
needs to be done to ensure that workplaces in Saskatchewan are harassment free.
I’d like to read the prayer:
We, in the prayer
that reads as follows, respectfully request the Legislative Assembly of
Saskatchewan call on the Government of Saskatchewan to improve conditions for
Saskatchewan workers by passing legislation to increase the minimum wage,
guarantee paid sick leave, limit nondisclosure agreements which could silence
survivors of workplace harassment, and require employers to track and report
incidents of violence and harassment in the workplace.
Mr. Speaker, those provisions are all
included in our private member’s bill, Bill 613, the fairer workplaces,
better jobs Act. Mr. Speaker, we do hope that the minister looks at that bill
closely and passes all of it into legislation this session; if not, takes parts
of it that are very reasonable and passes them expeditiously.
Mr. Speaker, the individuals who have
signed this petition today come from Regina. I do so present.
[13:45]
The Speaker:
— I recognize the member from Athabasca.
Mr.
Lemaigre: — Thank you, Mr.
Speaker. I’m very proud to be a fluent speaker of my people’s language, Denesuline, but because the policies that were aimed at
annihilating the use of traditional languages, many Indigenous people do not
speak their language in Saskatchewan. That’s why our government is providing
over $108,000 to the First Nations University of Canada to deliver the Dene and
Cree teacher education program in Hatchet Lake Denesuline
Nation and Waterhen Lake First Nation.
Mr. Speaker, this funding is part of a
partnership that allows students in the Dene teacher education program and the
Cree teacher education program to study in their home communities. These
programs enable students to learn at home in their first language.
Mr. Speaker, when these students
graduate they will receive a Bachelor of Indigenous Education and will be able
to teach K to 12 [kindergarten to grade 12] education in an Indigenous language
or with a focus on Indigenous practices. The Indigenous teacher education
programs are helping build a future where more Indigenous youth can learn in
their own language, helping to retain their cultural and linguistic heritage.
Mr. Speaker, we are proud to support
Indigenous students and their communities through this important partnership.
We are not only creating post-secondary opportunities for students in the
North, but we are supporting the success of Indigenous children and their
family. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Walsh Acres.
Mr. Clarke:
— Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It is my honour to rise today to recognize Team
Simpson, Saskatchewan’s under‑18 provincial curling champs. Team Sask is made up of Lauren and Katelyn Speidel, along with
teammates Shawna Simpson — the three of them all hail from Winston Knoll
Collegiate in Regina — and Makena Bailey from Greenall High School. Together
they won the provincial championship on December 30th, 2023, and secured a spot
at nationals in Ottawa. Gaylene Simpson helped mentor and guide the team as
their coach.
In Ottawa, Team Saskatchewan played with
determination and class, and they certainly demonstrated that they can play on
the national level. Lauren and Katelyn reached out to my office to request some
Saskatchewan pins and flags to take with them to Ottawa, and it was a pleasure
to fulfill that request.
Curling is a popular sport in
Saskatchewan and an important recreational activity to continue to nurture. It
provides all generations an opportunity to exercise, to socialize, to build
community and, of course, have fun.
Saskatchewan is proud of Team Simpson’s
accomplishments at provincials and at nationals, and these four young women are
role models for other young curlers in this province. I certainly look forward
to seeing what their future holds on the ice. I ask all members of this
Legislative Assembly to congratulate Team Simpson for their achievements this
season and for their dedication to sportsmanship, skill development, and
personal growth through active lifestyle choices. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Prince
Albert Northcote.
Ms.
A. Ross: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Last fall I
met with Emily, a former U of S [University of Saskatchewan] nursing student
recently hired at the Victoria Hospital in Prince Albert. She asked me why
Prince Albert wasn’t part of the student loan forgiveness program.
I took that question to the Minister of
Advanced Education, and I am pleased to say that, on January 24th, our
government announced the expanded Saskatchewan loan forgiveness for nurses and
nurse practitioners program to include the five communities of Prince Albert,
Moose Jaw, Swift Current, Yorkton, and The Battlefords. This initiative
supports Saskatchewan’s health human resources action plan, the most ambitious
plan in the nation, by providing incentives to work in areas with high
recruitment needs.
This initiative also helps nursing
students stay in or close to home, like the fourth-year nursing student in
Prince Albert who has two children under the age of six. She said when she
heard about this program it brought tears to her eyes because of how it would
help her family.
We are opening doors for our citizens to
pursue a career in nursing, we are easing the financial burden, and we are
serving the needs of the residents through our recruitment and retention
efforts.
Mr. Speaker, thank you to all those
nursing students and nurse practitioner students who choose to stay and work
here in Saskatchewan. Thank you.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Elphinstone-Centre.
Ms.
Conway: — Today I’d like to shine a light on
the incredible work being done at Regina’s Mobile Crisis. Mobile Crisis offers
a variety of integrated and comprehensive emergency supports and health crisis
interventions. They also run the Farm Stress and the problem gambling
helplines.
Mobile Crisis is on the cusp of a few
changes. They’re set to move into a new space at the YWCA centre for women and
families in about six months. They’re also saying goodbye to their executive
director, Janet Thorson, after nearly 40 years with the organization, most of
which was spent on the front line beginning as a practicum student.
Jan has led them through some high
points and some challenging times as well. I’m grateful to have sat down with
the outgoing and incoming leadership last week at the request of one of my
practicum students.
Over Jan’s tenure the need has
increased. At one point, 50 calls over a 24‑hour span was considered an
exhausting day. These days they routinely break 100 calls a day. Like so many
CBO [community-based organization] non-profits, they do tough work with not
nearly enough supports. There’s more work and it’s gotten more complex. Funding
hasn’t kept up with the need and they haven’t been able to hire additional
staff in 20 years.
That said, under Jan’s steady hand, the
team has never wavered in their deep commitment to offering valuable, often
life-saving services to vulnerable communities. I know the team at Mobile
Crisis will continue to do good work under their new leadership of Dana
Wilkins. I’d ask all members to join me in thanking Jan for four decades of
exemplary public service defined by compassion and dedication.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Cypress
Hills.
Mr.
Steele: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. For
generations Saskatchewan people have gathered at the regional parks with
families, friends, and neighbours. We want this tradition to continue. Mr.
Speaker, our government has doubled the funding for Saskatchewan Regional Parks
Association. A total investment of 1.2 million to support our parks have
. . . increase of 615,000. This money will be used to help pay for
improvements and maintenance.
And we’re also investing 15 million
into our capital and infrastructure improvements for our provincial parks. My
own constituency will be getting a new playground at Cypress Hills park that
will be open this summer. Thanks to the 13.3 million dedicated to capital
funding, several other facilities will be also built in other parks.
Mr. Speaker, this funding will be well
used by people of Saskatchewan as they set out to experience world-class parks
this spring and the summer. Reservations for seasonal campsites are opening
April 1st and April 2nd for nightly and group sites, with more parks opening
every day until April 9th.
Our government is committed to
maintaining our parks well into the future. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from
Saskatoon Westview.
Mr.
Buckingham: — Mr. Speaker, today we received historic
notice about Saskatchewan’s growing population. According to StatsCan 2023 Q4 [fourth quarter] data, Saskatchewan’s population reached
the new all-time high of 1,225,493. From January 1st, 2023 to January 1st,
2024, the population increased by 30,624, the largest population increase in a
single calendar year since 1914.
This incredible growth is further proof
that our province remains one of the most attractive jurisdictions not just in
this nation but globally. It is no secret that growth is something we didn’t
have under the previous NDP government. In fact, under the NDP, Saskatchewan’s
population declined by 22,000 people. Only luggage sales increased under the
NDP as young people were forced to flee the province for greener pastures
elsewhere.
Thankfully that is no longer the case.
Since our government was elected, Saskatchewan’s population has increased by
225,000 people, with more increases daily. And as we continue to grow we are
meeting the challenges of that growth with a budget that makes record
investments into classrooms, care, and communities.
Our government will continue working to
ensure our growing province is building a strong economy and a bright future
for all residents.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Martensville-Warman.
Mr.
Jenson: — Well thank you very much, Mr.
Speaker. This morning our Premier appeared before the federal Standing
Committee on Government Operations and Estimates, but not before Liberal and
NDP committee members attempted to block the Premier from standing up for
Saskatchewan.
The NDP member from Quebec called
Canadians laggards in reducing emissions. Did the Leader of the Opposition call
her federal leader and stand up for Saskatchewan people? Did she remind her
federal brothers and sisters that Saskatchewan is part of Canada and we are not
laggards? Did she remind them that Saskatchewan has the cleanest and most
ethically produced oil and gas and agriculture products on earth? Did she tell
them that if you want a clean environment, you’d buy from Saskatchewan?
Did she stand up for Saskatchewan or
does she stand with her own MLAs [Member of the Legislative Assembly] who
support a carbon tax when they say things like, the need for a carbon tax is
“not up for debate any longer”; “why shouldn’t consumers actually pay for the
price of carbon for producing food”; and “spoiler: I’m in favour of a carbon
tax”?
When will the Leader of the Opposition
and members of that party finally find their feet and stand with the Premier,
denounce the federal Trudeau-Singh carbon tax coalition, and stand up for
Saskatchewan people?
The
Speaker: — I
recognize the Leader of the Opposition.
Ms.
Beck: — Now, Mr. Speaker, earlier today the
Premier had a lot to say about what other people should be doing to help with
the cost of living. But it’s this Premier, Mr. Speaker, who failed to provide
any cost-of-living relief in his own budget, and this at a time when 57 per
cent of Saskatchewan people are struggling just to pay their groceries.
Mr. Speaker, does the Premier not
understand? Doesn’t he get that he has no leg to stand on when it comes to
calling out the feds on the lack of cost-of-living relief when he won’t lift a
finger to do anything here at home?
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Premier.
Hon.
Mr. Moe: — Mr. Speaker, yeah, we were on a
committee with the federal parliament this morning discussing the inflationary
concerns — that, I think, in fairness we share in this province and across
Canada — of the carbon tax. In particular when it comes to a carbon tax that
traditionally, outside of Quebec, has been a harmful tax and a harmful policy,
but is at least been somewhat fairly applied across the nation. That all
changed when the federal coalition government made a decision to remove the
carbon tax off home heating fuel, largely impacting those families in Atlantic
Canada.
What we had asked and continue to ask
the federal government to do is to treat all Canadian families fairly, Mr.
Speaker. Remove the carbon tax off of all home heating fuels, all types, which
would then allow all families to not pay that harmful tax, at least on the fuel
that we utilize in heating our homes.
So what we have done in Saskatchewan,
Mr. Speaker, what we’ve done in Saskatchewan is acted where we can act. And
we’ve removed that carbon tax from home heating fuel that we control — SaskEnergy, Mr. Speaker — so off our natural gas customers
as well as any of those, largely in northern Saskatchewan, that might use
electric heat, Mr. Speaker.
The savings is about $400 a year for a
family, Mr. Speaker. We feel that’s significant. It’s more than the $128 that
is being received by an Ontario family, Mr. Speaker, in the reduction of their
gas tax, Mr. Speaker. It’s significant cost savings, in addition, in addition
to the $2 billion that is present in this budget each and every year.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Leader of the
Opposition.
Ms.
Beck: — Mr. Speaker, this tired and
out-of-touch government is failing to deliver when it comes to the cost of
living. And they’re failing to deliver when it comes to creating good jobs and
growing the economy. Last Friday the year-end numbers for businesses gained or
lost throughout the country were released, and in 2023 Saskatchewan lost 372
businesses.
Does the Premier think that it’s the
sign of a strong economy that we’ve lost more than 370 businesses last year
alone?
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Premier.
Hon.
Mr. Moe: — Mr. Speaker, where we are year over
year in this province is we’re up over 18,000 jobs, Mr. Speaker. That’s over
1,000 jobs each and every month, about 1,500 jobs each and every month here in
the province. That’s the last year, Mr. Speaker, and we’re creating jobs at a
quicker pace than we ever have in our history.
Also, Mr. Speaker, more people are
moving here, more people are staying here. We’re long past the days of where
Saskatchewan’s fastest growing city was Calgary, Mr. Speaker, long past those
days. Mr. Speaker, 30,000 people chose to move here, stay here just last year.
Mr. Speaker, our population is up 30,000 people. We’re growing at a rate faster
than we have ever grown in the history of our province, Mr. Speaker.
That’s because we are a place that is
attracting investment into the mining industry, into the ag value-added
industry, Mr. Speaker, into even the oil industry in this day and age, which we
discussed this morning on the federal committee call that I was on, Mr.
Speaker.
[14:00]
So Saskatchewan is really working
against . . . working, Mr. Speaker. Despite some of the decisions
that the federal government has made, Saskatchewan is having successes in
attracting investment, creating jobs, and attracting people to live here in our
communities right across the province, Mr. Speaker. That’s why you saw a record
investment this year in classrooms, care, and communities to ensure that those
folks in our communities, Mr. Speaker, those families that are moving to our
communities have the supports that they expect.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Leader of the
Opposition.
Ms.
Beck: — It’s a lot of words not to answer
the question, Mr. Speaker. And no matter how you slice it, these numbers speak
for themselves. It’s not good news, Mr. Speaker. Regina lost 78 businesses,
Saskatoon lost 131, and 163 were lost elsewhere. When this Premier came to
office, there were 24,891 active businesses in this province. And since then
we’ve lost 230.
How does the Premier defend the fact
that there are 230 fewer businesses in this province than there were when he
came to office?
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Trade
and Export Development.
Hon.
Mr. J. Harrison: — There they go again, Mr. Speaker.
Every chance they get they try and talk down the economy, they attack our job
creators, they attack our businesses.
Today we had some historic news, Mr.
Speaker, something that they won’t even acknowledge: the fact that our
population is growing at a rate that it has never grown at before, Mr. Speaker.
Over the course of the last year 30,000 new people are calling Saskatchewan
home. That is something that we are proud of, Mr. Speaker. It’s something that
the public of this province are proud of, and it’s something that the NDP are
now heckling about from across the floor.
I think, Mr. Speaker, that’s says
everything you know about the New Democrats, a party that lost population
during their 16 years in power, Mr. Speaker. We created 18,000 jobs over the
course of the last year. The future in this province is incredibly bright and
the 30,000 new Saskatchewan residents know that is the case.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Leader of the
Opposition.
Ms.
Beck: — Mr. Speaker, the minister wants a
gold star, but the fact that there 230 fewer businesses with more people, Mr.
Speaker, explains why unemployment is forecast to go up in their own budget.
And these are the facts.
And the facts show that this Premier has
the worst economic record in the country. During this Premier’s time in office,
we’ve seen less than 1 per cent, less than 1 per cent economic growth, and the
budget is forecast to be only 1 per cent in the coming years. The Premier also,
Mr. Speaker, has the worst job creation record in the country. Now Saskatchewan
people, they don’t care about spin. They want results.
How does the Premier defend the record
on the economy, a record of losing hundreds of businesses?
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Trade
and Export Development.
Hon.
Mr. J. Harrison: — What utter nonsense from the NDP,
Mr. Speaker, a party that takes every opportunity to be negative, a party that
has no plan for the future, Mr. Speaker. And we know that because when they
were in government, they lost people. They destroyed jobs. They sent young
people fleeing to Calgary.
Today alone, Mr. Speaker, we have this
incredible news. We have added, in the last year alone, a city the size of
Moose Jaw — in the last year alone, Mr. Speaker. Over the course of the last 16
years, we have added a city the size of Regina, Mr. Speaker.
They chased everybody out of the
province. They nationalized businesses. They had people and companies leaving
in droves, Mr. Speaker.
On this side of the House we know — and
the 30,000 people who’ve moved to Saskatchewan know — our future is incredibly bright.
And they’ve chosen to make their home right here in Saskatchewan.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Elphinstone-Centre.
Ms.
Conway: — Mr. Speaker, this tired and
out-of-touch government is quickly earning the reputation of one that does
everything they possibly can to conceal real facts from the people of
Saskatchewan. We see that through the way that this government responds to FOIs
[freedom of information], how they answer questions in this Assembly. And we
saw that last week with the release of the budget.
It’s a time-honoured, long-standing
practice that opposition members get to attend a technical briefing with
government officials in the public service to ask questions about the details
of the budget. We asked a number of detailed questions, and undertakings were
made to provide answers before the end of the day.
It’s been a week and there’s still been
no answer. When will we finally get answers that we were promised?
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Finance.
Hon.
Ms. Harpauer: — Indeed, as the member opposite said,
it’s been a long-standing tradition that the members in opposition get a
technical briefing with the officials. The morning of the budget they can ask
their questions. I do not attend that, Mr. Speaker, so therefore I am not aware
of what questions they have asked.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Elphinstone-Centre.
Ms.
Conway: — Mr. Speaker, getting answers to
basic questions out of this tired and out-of-touch government, it’s like
pulling teeth. The information we were asking was all very straightforward.
Questions like, what is the forest fire budget? What’s the breakdown of school
division funding? What are the potential costs of the teachers’ contracts?
These are basic questions that have
clear answers, and the Sask Party should be able to
provide them in a timely way. How does the Finance minister justify one week of
radio silence on these basic requests for information about her budget?
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Finance.
Hon.
Ms. Harpauer: — Mr. Speaker, I am sure that the
member opposite would be very pleased to know that all of those questions can
be asked specific to the ministries they apply to and the minister who is
responsible for those ministries in budget estimates. And they get to request
how many hours they want in each of those budgets, 75 hours in total.
So the member opposite would be very
pleased to know that they will get the answers to the questions on that format.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina Elphinstone-Centre.
Ms. Conway: — Mr. Speaker, it’s increasingly clear that this
tired and out-of-touch government is increasingly allergic to transparency. We
see that in the way that they fail to answer basic questions about their
budget, and we saw that yesterday in response to my questions about the Thriftlodge motel.
I asked, again
and again, how much money did that Minister of Social Services pay out to the Thriftlodge motel, the same motel that the Sask Party member for Regina Northeast is an investor in.
When will we
finally get an answer on the payments made in each of the last five years? It’s
not that hard, Mr. Speaker.
The Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Social Services.
Hon.
Mr. Makowsky: — Mr. Speaker,
we’ve been over this many times. I’ve provided an extensive amount of
information to that member. She subsequently asked for more information and, as
I indicated yesterday, that will be provided in due course, Mr. Speaker.
In terms of hotel expenditures, Mr.
Speaker, in general the amount of hotels, particularly here in Regina, has
decreased that are willing to work with — especially on the income assistance
side — with challenges with individuals that might be staying and might need
services, Mr. Speaker. And so, therefore as a result there’ll be more
expenditures in less amount of hotels, Mr. Speaker.
What the member opposite didn’t do
yesterday as well is answer my question, and when asked about it in the media
had absolutely no answer, Mr. Speaker. What is the amount that we should not
use to pay for an individual who’s in a very difficult situation, Mr. Speaker?
The member talked about Mobile Crisis in her member’s statement . . .
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Elphinstone-Centre.
Ms.
Conway: — Another minister auditioning for
opposition. We love to see it, Mr. Speaker.
He says he’ll provide it in due course.
And indeed, Mr. Speaker, yesterday in the rotunda the minister said finally
that he would provide some answers on that Thriftlodge
motel, and that the answers would come before the end of session. The end of
session, Mr. Speaker.
This is a government that has enough
staff to lurk outside our office and watch who comes and goes from question
period prep. They have thousands of staff at their disposal in the civil
service, and their commitment is to provide five numbers before the May long
weekend. What a joke.
Mr. Speaker, there’s no time like the
present. When will we get these details? When will the minister just rip off
the band-aid and come clean with how much he’s paid to his officemate’s Thriftlodge motel in each of the last five years?
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Social
Services.
Hon.
Mr. Makowsky: — Mr. Speaker,
it’s interesting, her member statement. I thought it was a great one today
about Mobile Crisis and how important they are to vulnerable people in our
province. They very often refer people to hotels. So, Mr. Speaker, would that
member tell Mobile Crisis that there’s an amount that we can’t help a
vulnerable person in our province, Mr. Speaker? So if she wants to not spend on
that, she should say what the alternative should be, Mr. Speaker.
We’re going to continue to work on this,
Mr. Speaker, first of all, to help vulnerable people. Number two, on the policy
side, we’re going to increase . . . We’re going to look at the amount
of hotels we use, hopefully get a better rate going forward, Mr. Speaker. But
at the end of the day, it’s got to be about vulnerable people in our province,
which that member advocates for.
She asked for hotels from the ministry
and Mobile Crisis, Mr. Speaker. So again, I ask here: what is the number that
she would not house someone for the night in a vulnerable situation?
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from
Saskatoon Eastview.
Mr.
Love: — Mr. Speaker, this tired and
out-of-touch government deserves an F when it comes to basic transparency. And
they deserve an F-minus when it comes to their record on education. Now the
minister loves to talk about record funding in the budget. We’ve heard that
same rhetoric from the minister before him and the minister before him and the
minister before him.
But when you factor in inflation, Mr.
Speaker, this budget provides 436 million less in supports than the first
budget brought under this Premier’s watch back in 2018. How can the Sask Party put classrooms into the slogan for their budget
when they’ve done such a terrible job in providing the supports our students
need?
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of
Education.
Hon.
Mr. Cockrill: — Well, Mr. Speaker, it’s good to see
both the STF [Saskatchewan Teachers’ Federation] and
the NDP this week using letter grades. It’s nice to see that they’re endorsing
a return to letter grades and report cards that can be understood by parents
and students alike, Mr. Speaker.
But, Mr. Speaker, let me just say this,
as I’ve outlined many times on this floor before. This province — the taxpayers
of this province — invest more into K to 12 education per capita than any other
province in the country, Mr. Speaker. That means more of their tax dollars, my
tax dollars, your tax dollars go into our K to 12 education system every single
year, Mr. Speaker, to support our students, Mr. Speaker.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from
Saskatoon Eastview.
Mr.
Love: — And we now have the Minister of
Education deriding his own ministry’s policies on the floor of the Assembly,
and it certainly tracks for a tired and out-of-touch government that has taken
hundreds of millions worth of purchasing power away from local divisions.
That’s a fact.
It’s also a fact that we’ve added
thousands more students during that time, hundreds of whom were out protesting
this government in front of the office of the member from Saskatoon Southeast.
And they’re protesting because they see classroom complexity has grown
unmanageable under this government. There are more students today than six
years ago, more of them who need additional supports. But this minister isn’t
giving divisions the tools they need to support students. This budget will
likely result in more school division cuts.
Will the minister accept responsibility
for those cuts, or will he do what the Sask Party
always does and blame school boards for those cuts?
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of
Education.
Hon.
Mr. Cockrill: — We’re not sure who to believe over
there, Mr. Speaker. In one breath, people are leaving our province. In another
breath, people are coming to this province and filling our classrooms and
filling our hospitals, which is why we need to invest more into education and
health care, which this government accomplishes, Mr. Speaker. The largest ever
increase to school operating funding, Mr. Speaker, to the 27 school divisions
all around the province, Mr. Speaker.
For that member to stand up and say
there’s going to be cuts, Mr. Speaker, school divisions are still working on
their budget for the next school year and are appreciative of the increase that
was offered in this year’s budget. We look forward to working with those school
divisions to ensure that supports reach the classroom, Mr. Speaker.
And again, I would point to the
classroom supports funding, Mr. Speaker, and the multi-year funding agreement
that we’ve signed with the 27 school divisions, providing predictability at a
base floor of funding for the next four years. Mr. Speaker, we’re going to
continue working with those school divisions and ensuring that that supports
funding reaches our students each and every single day.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from
Saskatoon Eastview.
Mr.
Love: — Mr. Speaker, we’re here talking
about this government’s failed record in education. Their funding hasn’t kept
pace with inflation. And it’s clear as day in the staffing documents that we
had to FOI just to get our hands on. They show that 15,000 new students have
been added to our system since 2016, but only one new classroom teacher during
that time period. It doesn’t make any sense, and it’s why teachers and parents
and now students are done with this minister and this tired and out-of-touch
government.
[14:15]
How does the Minister of Education
defend hiring only one classroom teacher for 15,000 new students?
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Education.
Hon.
Mr. Cockrill: — Mr. Speaker, I don’t know why the
member opposite would have to FOI the education staffing profile. It’s
available publicly on Saskatchewan.ca and the
Ministry of Education website, Mr. Speaker.
Mr. Speaker, at the end of the day, Mr.
Speaker, at the end of the day it is the 27 school divisions that hire the
teachers and support staff and professionals that serve our students in
communities all around the province, Mr. Speaker. That member would know well,
having worked in the education system, that staffing numbers do fluctuate.
But, Mr. Speaker, what we are seeing is
more students, more supports, and more teachers in our classrooms all across
the province in addition to the additional investments that we’re making in
education capital. Mr. Speaker, a record $216 million being invested into
education capital in this next fiscal year alone, building schools, renovating
schools, and making sure that we have great facilities and great support staff
for our students to learn from.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Coronation Park.
Mr.
Burki: — Thank you,
Mr. Speaker. New numbers out today show that Saskatchewan population growth,
which started under the NDP, continues. It’s the great news that thousands of
people are moving here from around the world. But when you look at the details,
it is clear that this tired and out-of-touch government isn’t doing enough to
ensure that the newcomers come over here to Saskatchewan . . .
[inaudible] . . . to this government and be living over here in a
good state.
Only 58 per
cent of newcomers who arrived here five years ago are still living here. Does
the Sask Party government think it is acceptable more
than 40 per cent of newcomers pick up and leave this province within the next
five years?
The Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Trade and Export
Development.
Hon. Mr. J. Harrison: — Well I think everybody has just seen exhibit A,
why the NDP have no credibility, Mr. Speaker. The member before is standing up
demanding more funding for education, saying the population is growing so
quickly, Mr. Speaker, you have to put in tons more money.
The member
then stands up, Mr. Speaker, and says everybody’s leaving. You guys have to get
your stories straight, Mr. Speaker. You can’t change question to question. The
reality is, which we saw today from Stats Canada which is an organization that
doesn’t lie, Mr. Speaker, showed that 30,000 new Canadians have made their home
here in Saskatchewan. Mr. Speaker, something that we are incredibly proud of,
something that everybody in this province should be
proud of, not criticizing like the members opposite.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Coronation Park.
Mr.
Burki: — Mr. Speaker, 42 per cent of
newcomers leaving within five years, and that number is getting worse.
Saskatchewan has seen the largest decline in immigrant retention of all the
provinces during the Premier’s time in this government. That is a fact. We
should welcome our newcomers to this province, but we need to make sure we
provide the support that they need.
Why is the Sask
Party government seeing the largest drop in immigration retention out of all
the provinces in the country?
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Trade
and Export Development.
Hon.
Mr. J. Harrison: — Well you know, again, Mr. Speaker,
we’re seeing why this is an opposition with no credibility, Mr. Speaker. The
reality is that this province is growing and this province is growing at a rate
that it has never grown before.
Over the course of the last 16 years,
Mr. Speaker, we have added 250,000 new people to our provincial population.
That’s a growth rate of 25 per cent, something that we have never seen in the history
of this province before, Mr. Speaker. Something that we are proud of, and
frankly I think something that everybody in this province is proud of, adding a
new city the size of Regina over the course of the time that we have had the
opportunity and honour of forming government.
And the reason that we have been able to
do that, Mr. Speaker, is because we have created jobs. We have created
opportunities. We have worked with our job creators to create those
opportunities so newcomers, whether they be from outside of Saskatchewan or
outside of Canada, can make their home here, build their lives here, have their
families here, and have a wonderful life.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from
Saskatoon University.
Ms.
Bowes: — Mr. Speaker, 476 lives were lost to
overdose last year. In Saskatoon alone, 85 families lost a loved one to this
crisis. But this overdose crisis isn’t only happening in our urban areas, Mr.
Speaker. It’s also happening, changing the lives of people in rural areas like
Yorkton, Wynyard, Stoughton, Preeceville, Nipawin, Punnichy, and the list goes on. Nearly every community has
been impacted by this crisis in one way or another.
Will the minister finally admit that his
plan isn’t working and commit to providing evidence-based supports to save
lives today?
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Mental
Health and Addictions.
Hon.
Mr. T. McLeod: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And
certainly our government is well aware that challenges of addictions aren’t
only isolated to our large cities. They extend across our province, across the
country, and certainly across the world, Mr. Speaker. And that’s why, with the
500 addictions treatment spaces that we are adding, we’re seeing those added across
the province, Mr. Speaker. We’ve added spaces in Lloydminster. We’ve added
spaces in Regina, North Battleford, Estevan. We’ve added virtual spaces, Mr.
Speaker, that individuals across the province can access. In fact one of the
spaces that we added, Mr. Speaker, is in North Battleford at Poundmaker’s
Lodge.
And I would like to thank the member
from Saskatoon Centre for her support on that, Mr. Speaker. Here’s a quote that
she gave CBC [Canadian Broadcasting Corporation] when she said:
This treatment centre
is from an Indigenous perspective, and as the critic for First Nations and
Métis Relations, it’s important for me to show support for programming that is
being developed here in Saskatchewan. Saskatchewan definitely needs this.
Mr. Speaker, we agree.
The
Speaker: — I’d just like to caution the members
in general about your language. So there’s three cases I’m going to cite. And
the first one is the member from Regina Elphinstone-Centre said, “When will the
minister come clean,” and that suggests the minister is not being honest. Will
the member stand and withdraw and apologize.
Ms.
Conway: — Mr. Speaker, I withdraw and
apologize.
The
Speaker: — The second case is by the Minister
of Education. He said, “Not sure who to believe” — suggests lying. Will the
minister please stand and withdraw and apologize?
Hon.
Mr. Cockrill: — Withdraw and apologize, Mr. Speaker.
The
Speaker: — Third case is by the Minister of
Trade and Export Development said, “An organization that doesn’t lie” —
inappropriate. Will the minister stand and withdraw and apologize?
Hon.
Mr. J. Harrison: — Withdraw and apologize.
The
Speaker: — [Inaudible interjection] . . .
Would the minister stand and withdraw and apologize again for what he just
said?
Hon. Mr. J. Harrison:
— Withdraw and apologize.
The Speaker:
— I recognize the Minister of Finance.
Hon.
Ms. Harpauer: — Mr. Speaker, I move that Bill
No. 156, the tobacco Act amendment Act, 2024 be now introduced and read a
first time.
The
Speaker: — It has been moved by the Minister of
Finance that Bill No. 156 be introduced and read a first time. Is it the
pleasure of the Assembly to adopt the motion?
Some
Hon. Members: — Agreed.
The
Speaker: — Carried.
Deputy
Clerk: — First reading of this bill.
The
Speaker: — When shall the bill be read a second
time? I recognize the Minister of Finance.
Hon.
Ms. Harpauer: — Next sitting of this Assembly, Mr.
Speaker.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Finance.
Hon.
Ms. Harpauer: — Mr. Speaker, I move that Bill
No. 157, The Income Tax Amendment Act, 2024 be now introduced and
read a first time.
The
Speaker: — It has been moved by the Minister of
Finance that Bill No. 157 be now introduced and read a first time. Is it
the pleasure of the Assembly to adopt the motion?
Some
Hon. Members: — Agreed.
The
Speaker: — Carried.
Deputy Clerk:
— First reading of this bill.
The
Speaker: — When shall the bill be read a second
time? I recognize the Minister of Finance.
Hon.
Ms. Harpauer: — Next sitting of the Assembly, Mr.
Speaker.
The
Speaker: — Next sitting.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the Minister of Trade
and Export Development.
Hon.
Mr. J. Harrison: — I move that Bill No. 158, The
Saskatchewan Commercial Innovation Incentive (Patent Box) Amendment Act, 2024
be now introduced and read a first time.
The
Speaker: — It has been moved by the Minister of
Trade and Export Development that Bill No. 158 be introduced and read a
first time. Is it the pleasure of the Assembly to adopt the motion?
Some
Hon. Members: — Agreed.
The
Speaker: — Carried.
Deputy Clerk:
— First reading of this bill.
The
Speaker: — When shall the bill be read a second
time? I recognize the minister.
Hon.
Mr. J. Harrison: — Next sitting.
The
Speaker: — Next sitting.
[The Assembly resumed the adjourned
debate on the proposed motion by the Hon. Ms. Harpauer that the Assembly
approves in general the budgetary policy of the government, and the proposed
amendment to the main motion moved by Mr. Wotherspoon.]
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Coronation Park.
Mr.
Burki: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I was the
debater yesterday and we finished at 10:30, for the Deputy Speaker was not
letting me go on till 11 o’clock and that was heartbreaking. I guess he was
fasting and that’s why. He was really more hungry or might be thirsty, but same
is on my side too. So we’ll start from the point where I stopped.
The
Speaker: — I’d just like to remind the member
not to bring the Chair into debate.
Mr. Burki: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We all know the
importance of education. Spending money on education is not a cost; it is the
best investment ever. And every single person in this Chamber, every member
wants to see that their child be growing, their child should be successful. And
the launching pad for each and every child in this world is education.
If you look to education in our province
compared with other provinces, we can see a lot of deficiency in that. We have
to work honestly to make sure we can sincerely work for the future of our
children, to make sure our children be successful and thrive.
Most concerns that I heard from the
teachers are not regarding anything else, but the only thing that I got, that
is the cuts in education, overcrowded classrooms, shortage of teacher
assistants, language pathologists, psychologists, ESL [English as a second
language] teachers for newcomers. These are all the main concerns, genuine
concerns of the teachers.
I would humbly request this Government
of Saskatchewan to fully fund our educational institutions, to come to the
bargaining table, and sign a fair contract with the teachers so that our
students are successful lifelong.
Mr. Speaker, on the budget day we saw
approximately 4,000 to 600 teachers with their supporters protesting outside
the Legislative Building to call on government to get a fair deal done for our
kids. Our kids deserve the best learning conditions to set them up for success.
Mr. Speaker, our kids have spent years
in classrooms that have been overcrowded and underfunded. The people of
Saskatchewan deserve real results, not empty promises the government has no
intention of keeping on the eve of an election.
Mr. Speaker, I heard on the doorstep
from a lot of residents that they can’t find a job in Saskatchewan. An hon.
minister was saying we have a lot of jobs. I don’t know why people were telling
me that.
Our province has the lowest minimum wage
in the country. And the young generation is moving out of province. Young
people are the backbone of our communities and our economy and we must retain
them in our province by investing in local businesses. And we heard that local
businesses are closing. It is heartbreaking. And we have to minimize
outsourcing jobs.
Mr. Speaker, we know there’s increasing
crime and addictions, mental health in our province. Nearly 2,000 people have
lost their lives to overdose since this Premier took office — 476 lives lost to
overdose in 2023 alone. Seventy-four people have died due to overdose just in
January and February of this year alone. Every year we have record overdose in
the province, yet this government chooses to make . . . away support
that keep our people alive long enough to seek treatment.
[14:30]
Mr. Speaker, we know about the
increasing crime in our province. Saskatchewan had the highest rate of
violence-related crime, the second-highest homicide rate, the highest rate of
gender-related homicide of women and girls among the provinces. This government
is not willing to look to the underlying causes of crime; safe, affordable
housing; access to support and services in our communities.
Mr. Speaker, we know the contribution of
the small businesses in our communities and in our economy. Small businesses in
Saskatchewan are still recovering after the pandemic, not to mention
skyrocketing cost and budgetary increases from food to fuel, rent, and
utilities. Due to these rising costs, many small businesses have been forced to
close their doors. The recent SINP [Saskatchewan
immigrant nominee program] pause and the slow processing of hard-to-fill skills
programs . . . The small-business owners are looking for an option to
move to another province.
With that, Mr. Speaker, I will be voting
in favour of the amendment that was moved by my colleague from Rosemont and
seconded by the member from Regina Elphinstone-Centre. Thank you.
The
Speaker: — I recognize the member from
Saskatoon University.
Ms.
Bowes: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I look
forward to entering into the debate this afternoon in response to the
government’s budget. I rise today to express my disappointment with the budget,
which I will not be supporting for the following reasons.
Mr. Speaker, after 17 long years of this
Sask Party government, nothing seems to be working
right in Saskatchewan. Mr. Speaker, despite the government hype of record
investments, this budget is really nothing more than a status quo, lacklustre
budget. This budget does not even come close to repairing the damage that 17
years of neglecting public services has had on our quality of life in
Saskatchewan.
Despite record corporate profits and
record public debt, this budget will in no way provide the people of
Saskatchewan with a record quality of life. Last year Canadian corporations
continued to earn record corporate profits, Mr. Speaker. Yet despite these
record corporate profits, the Sask Party government
has refused to adjust resource royalty rates so that Saskatchewan people will
be able to reap the benefits of their natural resources.
Despite record corporate profits, this
government continues to rely on regressive property taxes to fund education.
And despite record corporate profits, this government has greedily continued to
rake in their expanded provincial sales tax on Saskatchewan residents during an
ongoing cost-of-living crisis. Under Scott Moe’s management, Saskatchewan is
projected to lose nearly a billion dollars in corporate taxes next year, Mr.
Speaker.
After 17 years of neglecting our public
health care system, the damage this government has caused is stark. Hospitals
across our province are routinely facing service disruptions as a result of
this government’s inability to hire and retain staff. Their four-point plan
isn’t working, Mr. Speaker. Patients continue to face unacceptable wait times
for tests and procedures, our hospitals are bursting at the seams, and it is
impossible for many Saskatchewan people to find a family doctor, Mr. Speaker.
This budget offers nothing more than the
status quo, with budget increases that won’t even cover the cost of inflation
in many cases. The increases to health spending in this budget have been hyped
as a record investment in health care, Mr. Speaker. Yet during this time of
record corporate profits, this government refuses to find the resources to fix
what they broke, to meaningly invest in our public health care system and to
meaningfully improve the quality of life for Saskatchewan people.
After 17 long years of this government
neglecting our public schools, student outcomes are declining, Mr. Speaker.
Over the past 17 years, students have lost teachers, educational assistants,
and specialists. Their classroom sizes have ballooned, all while student needs
have become increasingly complicated and demanding on teachers. Underfunded
classrooms certainly won’t be fixed by this status quo budget, Mr. Speaker.
While the Sask
Party government has drastically increased funding for private schools, they
have simultaneously put the squeeze on public classrooms. In a time of record
corporate profits, if now is not the time to fix underfunded classrooms, then
when is, Mr. Speaker? This government has hyped their budget as a record
funding increase for schools. Well it sure won’t be creating record outcomes for
students, Mr. Speaker, I can tell you that.
After 17 years of this Sask Party government, more and more people in Saskatchewan
simply cannot find affordable housing. Rents continue to go up and up, while
new builds are completely unaffordable for many. As Saskatchewan residents are
forced to dedicate more and more of their income to housing costs, they are in
turn experiencing a sharp decline in their quality of life.
The government’s hype with this budget
is to fund the upkeep of their existing government housing stock which they
have allowed to fall into a state of utter disrepair. Mr. Speaker, it is a
shame that in a time of record corporate profits this government refuses to
find the resources to truly fix their housing mess and increase the quality of
life for Saskatchewan people.
Providing child care spaces for those
who need them would greatly improve the quality of life for parents in
Saskatchewan, but this government simply isn’t getting the job done. With
record corporate profits, this government should be doing so much more to help
parents obtain quality child care for their children, Mr. Speaker.
This budget also creates record tuition
fees for university students. Seventeen years ago we had a tuition freeze in
this province, Mr. Speaker. And guess what? The Sask
Party government scrapped it. This government has provided universities with
budget increases that amount to less, which has caused tuition rates to soar
year after year in Saskatchewan.
On top of soaring tuition, students are
experiencing huge increases to their cost of living while this government
maintains the lowest poverty minimum wages in the country. Students should not
be forced to leave post-secondary with mountains of debt, Mr. Speaker. This
budget should be addressing the sky-high cost of obtaining a post-secondary
education instead of forcing students into record levels of crushing debt.
After 17 years of this government, Mr.
Speaker, finding affordable recreational opportunities has become harder and
harder. The cost of children’s sports, arts, and recreational activities
continues to rise, yet this budget sticks with the status quo, offering
boutique tax credits only to those who can afford to front the costs for their
children’s activities. This government should be directing recreational funds
towards lowering upfront costs for families. With record corporate profits, what
is stopping this government from increasing access to affordable recreational
opportunities for Saskatchewan children?
Mr. Speaker, it is no surprise that
after 17 long years, this Sask Party government has
presented us with yet another deficit budget. They continue to set record
levels of provincial government debt year after year. Like clockwork, once
again this budget naively projects that next year, next year the budget will be
balanced, Mr. Speaker. Fat chance of that happening.
This year’s budget marks a full decade
of Sask Party deficits, with the Premier increasing
the debt by a record-breaking $3 billion next year, bringing
Saskatchewan’s total debt to a staggering 34.8 billion. After 17 years of
telling us that next year the budget will be balanced, people in Saskatchewan
might just make it happen, Mr. Speaker, by voting in a different government to
write the next budget.
Mr. Speaker, while this budget creates a
record debt level for Saskatchewan, it also fails to deal with the impending
cost of the climate crisis. Failing to address the climate crisis now will only
cause the cost of addressing it to go up in the future. The failure of this
government to act is creating an off-the-books debt that will only have to be
addressed in the future.
Investing now in reducing greenhouse gas
emissions, investing in remediation and adaptation measures for our changing
climate, and investing in measures to reduce pollution now will save us money
down the road. If we invest now, we can spread the costs over a longer timeline
and decrease the work that will be needed in future, Mr. Speaker. But we won’t
be seeing that from this government. We can be certain of that.
So let’s recap, Mr. Speaker. After 17
long, painful years of this Sask Party government,
our health care system and our education system are worse off. After 17 years
of this Sask Party government, housing is less
affordable, and our minimum wage went from the second-highest in Canada to the
lowest — bottom of the barrel. After 17 long, long years of this government, it
is harder and harder for people in Saskatchewan to get by. After 17 years, the
status quo simply isn’t working for Saskatchewan people. After record debt,
record tuition fees, and record hype, this budget won’t be moving the needle to
improve the quality of life for Saskatchewan residents.
Mr. Speaker, with record corporate
profits there is no good reason why this government cannot find the resources
to make adequate investments to improve our health care system, to improve our
education system, to make housing more affordable, to lower tuition fees, to
provide better access to recreational opportunities, and to create more child
care spaces. The fact of the matter is this Sask
Party government is choosing to protect the record profits of their corporate
donors instead of investing in public services that will increase the quality
of life for all Saskatchewan residents, Mr. Speaker.
So for all of these reasons, Mr.
Speaker, I will not be supporting the budget motion, and I will instead be
supporting the amendment moved by the member for Regina Rosemont and seconded
by the member for Regina Elphinstone-Centre. With that I will conclude my
remarks. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
The
Deputy Speaker: — I would like to remind members not
to use the person’s name. Please use their ministry title or their
constituency. I recognize the member from Regina Northeast.
Mr.
Grewal: — Thank you. Mr. Speaker, I want to
begin today by thanking the people of Regina Northeast for their ongoing
support. Mr. Speaker, when I first came to this country approximately 41 years
ago, I started out by doing all sorts of odd jobs. I still remember those busy
days struggling with long hours trying to make ends meet. Somehow I still found
time to volunteer in my community. It has always been my passion right from my
childhood, Mr. Speaker. I am incredibly honoured and privileged to represent
Regina Northeast in this legislature. My dedication to public service has
always been rooted in a sincere desire to contribute to the betterment of the
community.
Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank my
family, especially my wife, Seema, and my children — Simran, Indu, TJ, Jag, and
Railin — for always taking the time away from their
own priorities to help me with my campaigns. Whether it was a nomination,
by-election, election, they were always there when I needed them. My heartfelt
thank you to my friends and volunteers who have taken significant roles in my
campaigns.
Mr. Speaker, I’m happy to share that I
have a new grandchild. Born on March 8th, this new addition to my family is my
fourth grandchild, Otto Arjay Grewal. Mila, Niam, and
Henry are so happy to have a new cousin and a little brother.
I am very grateful to my CA
[constituency assistant], Cheryl, for always helping my constituents, listening
to their concerns, and providing support when needed. I would also like to
extend a thank you to the caucus office for their support.
Mr. Speaker, last week our government
tabled budget 2024, which is focused on classrooms, care, and communities. It
is a budget that meets the needs of our Saskatchewan residents today while
ensuring a better future for tomorrow.
Many of the residents in my constituency
are struggling financially. I’m so pleased that this budget delivers more than 2 billion
in affordability measures. Mr. Speaker, tax exemptions provide Saskatchewan
people with over 830 million in annual income tax savings, allowing our
province to remain among the lowest personal taxes in the country. Our
residents will also continue to benefit from reduced education property tax and
programs and services designed to make life more affordable. This includes the
active families benefit, children’s drug plan, and programs to help fund
insulin pumps and glucose monitors.
[14:45]
Mr. Speaker, to make life more
affordable for low-income working families, a 17 million investment will
deliver the first full year of the Saskatchewan employment incentive program.
Our government’s decision to stop collecting the carbon tax on natural gas and electric
residential home heating will also provide additional relief, as it is expected
to save homeowners an average of $400 a year. To help homeowners with
affordability and improve housing availability, additional supports are
available, including the renewed PST [provincial sales tax] rebate on new home
construction program and the recently introduced Saskatchewan secondary suite
incentive grant program.
Mr. Speaker, with a record budget of
1.5 billion for the Ministry of Social Services, an increase of over
112 million compared to last year, this budget supports individuals,
families, and communities. The implementation of the provincial approach to
homelessness will also continue, supported by an increase of almost
17 million. This includes a 7.2 million increase to support ongoing
emergency shelter operations across the province and a 9.5 million capital
investment to continue developing supportive housing spaces in Regina and
Saskatoon.
The Saskatchewan Housing Corporation
will invest 83.4 million to repair and maintain provincially owned housing
units, including an additional 9.6 million in provincial funding to
prevent and reduce vacancies and respond to the increasing demand for social
housing. Monthly income assistance benefits will increase by 3 per cent for
Saskatchewan assured income for disability and Saskatchewan income support
clients. For seniors, the personal care home benefit monthly income threshold
will increase by 100 to 2,500 to help make living in a licensed care home more
affordable.
Mr. Speaker, this budget includes the
largest ever increase in school operating funding, the largest ever increase in
health funding, the largest ever increase in municipal revenue sharing for
Saskatchewan communities. And this is possible only because of our strong
economy. This shows our dedication to spending where it is needed but in a
sustainable way. Strong public services, including health care, have always
been foundational to our province.
Mr. Speaker, people are coming to
Saskatchewan in record numbers. People from across Canada and the world choose
to call Saskatchewan home because of our vast opportunities and reasonable cost
of living. They bring their skills as doctors, nurses, teachers, and people
working to build homes, hospitals, and schools. Saskatchewan’s population is
projected to reach a million and a quarter this year. Mr. Speaker, with this
vast increase in population, we need to ensure everyone has access to the
services we all count on.
For many people, quality health care is
at the top of their mind. New pressures are on our health care system including
a worldwide labour shortage, a retiring health care workforce, and a growing
population. We are taking steps to confront these challenges and strengthen
health care in our province.
A record investment of 7.6 billion
was allocated to the Saskatchewan health care system. This provides the
Saskatchewan Health Authority with nearly 4.7 billion, including an
operating increase of 248.3 million compared to last year. Over 71 million
focuses on increasing the capacity of the acute care system. This includes a
30 million funding increase to support the Saskatoon and Regina capacity
pressures action plans. Mr. Speaker, these plans include measures to enhance
acute care, community-based care, and emergency department capacity to support
our needs for hospital-based care.
The Regina urgent care centre will
receive an almost 10 million increase to support operations. This urgent
care centre will be available 24‑7 for non-life-threatening illness,
injuries, and mental health issues requiring same-day treatment, and will open
this summer. Mr. Speaker, funding is also being directed to reducing the
surgical wait-lists, working to achieve a three-month wait time target, years
ahead of schedule.
It also includes investments in the
health human resources action plan to hire, train, and retain more health care
professionals in the province. Additional funding in the budget provides
credential recognition supports, including streamlined and accelerated
assessments, training and licensure pathways, and settlement programming for
internationally trained health care workers.
So seniors can live safely and
comfortably in their home communities for as long as possible, the seniors’
care initiatives will receive a 43.4 million increase. Mr. Speaker, a
record budget of 574 million will be invested into mental health and
addiction programs and services, representing more than 7 per cent of health
care spending.
I am so pleased that this budget
includes investments to deliver timely, exceptional cancer care services for
our residents. The Saskatchewan Cancer Agency will receive an increase of over
26 million for a total record budget of almost 250 million to ensure
patients can access the most effective and cutting-edge treatment options. A
3.5 million increase for breast cancer care and screening includes
technology enhancements, new diagnostic imaging equipment, and the
establishment of a breast health centre in Regina.
Another area that is very important to
my constituents is education. This budget supports students and teachers
through a record investment of 3.3 billion for the Ministry of Education,
up 8.1 per cent over last year’s budget. This is an increase of
247.8 million to support pre-kindergarten to grade 12 students, early learning,
child care, and libraries.
Saskatchewan’s 27 school divisions will
receive 2.2 billion in school operating funding for the ’24‑25
school year, a record increase of 180 million over last year. This budget
is committed to addressing classroom size and complexity by providing
356.6 million in classroom support. Mr. Speaker, this is an increase of
45.6 million over last year and includes funding for the Teacher
Innovation and Support Fund pilot and a specialized support classroom pilot, which
aims to improve experiences for both students and teachers.
It includes 793 million in funding
for the post-secondary education sector, an increase of 3.7 per cent to enrich
the student experience and provide more opportunities for students to train and
pursue careers in Saskatchewan. Mr. Speaker, post-secondary students will
benefit directly from 46.5 million in financial supports, including a new
grant to help reduce financial barriers to completing post-secondary education
for low-income students with dependants.
The budget also includes continued
support for skills training programs and services for unemployed or
underemployed persons, including adult essential skills training,
pre-employment programs and services, credentialed skills training programs
through post-secondary institutions, and employment for persons with
disabilities.
Mr. Speaker, this budget spends wisely
to continue strengthening health care and education, with record spending on
health and education including new and modernized student classroom spaces. To
provide high-quality care, meet the needs of a growing province, and ensure our
health professionals have appropriate facilities to provide care to the people
of Saskatchewan, the ’24‑25 provincial budget invests a record
516.8 million in health infrastructure such as new hospitals and health
care centres. This is an increase of 179.3 million from the previous year
and includes almost 22 million to complete construction on the Regina
General Hospital parkade and 20 million for
Regina’s long-term care specialized beds project.
Mr. Speaker, the budget invests
216 million for pre-kindergarten to grade 12 education capital projects,
an increase of 41.8 per cent over last year. This includes ongoing funding for
11 projects, three significant renovations currently under way across
Saskatchewan, and funding for planning nine new schools and two renovations.
Also included is 28.5 million for relocatable classrooms and additional
32 million announced for relocatable classrooms late in ’23‑24
fiscal year.
Mr. Speaker, for cities, towns,
villages, and municipalities throughout Saskatchewan, this budget provides a
record increase of 42.4 million in municipal revenue sharing. This is an
increase of 14.2 per cent from the previous year for a total of 340 million
in unconditional support for provincial municipalities.
The budget provides twenty-nine and a
half million to support municipalities and industry partners in investing in
the provincial transportation system. These investments support economic growth
and safety on rural and municipality roads.
Mr. Speaker, there is 719.4 million
in this budget for the Ministry of Corrections, Policing and Public Safety.
This includes over 228 million to fund RCMP [Royal Canadian Mounted
Police] operations and 21.6 million for the RCMP’s First Nations policing
program. It also includes 7 million for the Saskatchewan marshals service
in anticipation of beginning operations in 2026.
Mr. Speaker, the Saskatchewan Public
Safety Agency will receive funding to renew its current air tanker fleet which
will approach the end of its useful life in 2027. The new fleet will support
wildfires and assist with other emergencies and public safety needs.
The ’24‑25 provincial budget
continues investment in First Nations and Métis communities throughout
Saskatchewan. More than 255 million in targeted funding will be provided
for First Nations and Métis people and organizations, an increase of
6.1 million over the previous year. This includes funding to help prevent
violence and build safety for Indigenous women, girls, and two-spirit people,
as well as support First Nations and Métis communities in participating in the
consultation process.
Mr. Speaker, our government is committed
to ensuring a strong economy. This budget illustrates our commitment to many
measures. One example is that our province will continue to have Canada’s
second-lowest small-business tax rate. The tax rate reduction to 1 per cent is
being extended until June 30th, 2025 and eligible business income tax threshold
tax will remain the highest threshold in Canada at 600,000.
Mr. Speaker, the Ministry of Trade and
Export Development will support the economy by expanding Saskatchewan’s
presence in international markets and attracting investment into the province
with a budget of 40.6 million. Expanding into markets outside of Canada is
essential to growing the Saskatchewan economy and leads to more jobs and
opportunities at home.
Mr. Speaker, this budget includes
53.8 million for the Ministry of Energy and Resources to support the
province’s growing economy focusing on Saskatchewan’s world-class natural
resources. It also introduces the clean electricity transition grant and the
small modular reactor investment fund. Revenues from the electricity sector will
be dedicated to priorities that support the province’s clean electricity
transition focusing on reliability and affordability.
[15:00]
From across the world, Mr. Speaker,
people travel to Saskatchewan to enjoy the province’s natural beauty and
experience world-class hunting and fishing. To ensure visitors have a great
experience, the ’24‑25 budget provides 15 million for capital and
infrastructure improvements at provincial parks in Saskatchewan.
This budget embodies the need to move
forward without repeating yesterday’s mistakes by striking a balance between
the need for fiscal sustainability and growing our province. We make
responsible choices to pay down debt, save for the future, and keep our
promises simultaneously. Mr. Speaker, budget 2024 proves that we are providing
a vision for the future, a future where our children and grandchildren can
enjoy the same advantages that we do today.
In conclusion I will say this, Mr.
Speaker. We need to remember that all the members in this legislature are just people.
As we engage in the cut and thrust of political discourse, let us not forget
the family behind these roles, the personal battles that are fought silently,
and the toll that public service can take on individuals and their loved ones.
Mr. Speaker, by remembering our
collective empathy, we can rebuild a political landscape that fosters a
constructive dialogue and a shared commitment to the welfare of our
constituents. Baseless accusations and character assassinations are just a
waste of time. Spreading disinformation does not help anyone. By working
together in a constructive way, we can accomplish so much more. It is my hope
that we can focus our energy on the issues that truly matter to the people we
serve.
I would like to take this opportunity
now to thank all my colleagues for the wonderful years spent together serving
the people of this beautiful province. With that, Mr. Speaker, I will support
this budget presented by the Minister of Finance and seconded by the member for
Saskatoon Willowgrove, and I do not support the
amendment. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
The
Deputy Speaker: — I
recognize the member from Cannington.
Mr. D. Harrison: — Thank you, Mr. Deputy Speaker. Mr. Deputy
Speaker, I want to begin by saying that I will be supporting the budget
presented by the hon. Finance minister and Deputy Premier, the member from
Humboldt-Watrous. Building and presenting budgets takes many hours, days, weeks
of hard work for the minister and her officials. To the minister, her
officials, and fellow treasury board members, I say thank you.
Mr. Deputy
Speaker, I want to thank the residents of Cannington for their
support in allowing me the honour to represent them here in the provincial
legislature. Mr. Deputy Speaker, I would also like to thank my constituency
assistants Trisha, April, and Merilyn. They do a fabulous job managing the
office, taking calls, and handling constituent concerns and inquiries. I also
want to thank the caucus staff for all their support with research and
communication, keeping me well informed, and being the central brain trust for
all the government MLAs.
As many have already said in this House,
we do not serve alone. Family support at home is critical for me to be here,
allowing me to serve and represent the great people of Cannington. My wife,
Cheryl, and son Thomas are attending our cow herd while I’m away. I know that
they’re doing a top-notch job, so much so that they are now telling me how
we’re going to do things. And it’s very hard for me to argue when they do all
the work.
A few weeks ago at the beef industry
conference during one of the coffee breaks, Ryder Lee, general manager of the
Canadian Cattle Association, had the quote of the conference in my opinion. It
was clearly pointed in my direction. Ryder says, “You just can’t have more cows
than your wife can feed.” And I had to agree. However Cheryl would always feed
more cows if there were more hours in the day. Cheryl, I love you and thank you
for all you do. Thanks to the rest of my family for their love and support. This
means more to me than you can imagine.
I would like to mention that we do have
a newer member of the family. Our granddaughter Hallie was born on March 12th —
8 pounds, 12 ounces. Mom and baby are doing very well. This makes number seven
grandchild, and the girls are out in front by a four to three count.
I’d also like to give a shout-out to my
mom, Eleanor, still living on the home place, keeping an eye out on the cows,
feeding her horses, dogs, and cats. Everyone around knows when you stop for a visit,
you cannot leave without getting something to eat. No matter what time of the
day, mom will always feed you. Mom, I love you and thank you for being you.
Mr. Deputy Speaker, I would like to
thank all of my colleagues. You have all made me feel very welcome and
encouraged me to be my best. Others have already singled out those not running
in the next election, and I must also acknowledge and thank those members as
well. I won’t tell any stories on them right now. However I want to thank and
acknowledge them for their service: the MLAs from Canora-Pelly, Batoche,
Yorkton, Kindersley, Regina Northeast, Arm River, Carrot River Valley,
Saskatoon Southeast, Indian Head-Milestone, Biggar-Sask Valley, Saskatoon Northwest,
Weyburn-Big Muddy, and Humboldt-Watrous. Each of you will hold a special place
in my heart and will be forever in my mind. Also to the members opposite who
are not seeking re-election, thank you for your service.
I want to give a special thank you to
the Deputy Premier — 25 years elected, 17 years in government, and 7 years as
Finance minister. That’s one heck of a career and a career to be proud of. I’ve
only been here for a few short years, but I have so much admiration and respect
for the member from Humboldt-Watrous. Thank you just doesn’t seem enough. To
all the retiring members, please enjoy your retirement. And for the ones not
old enough to retire, enjoy your future endeavours.
An
Hon. Member: — It’s age-related. Come on, Daryl.
Mr.
D. Harrison: — Yes it is, member from Kindersley. It
is age-related. Get to work.
Mr. Deputy Speaker, this budget is
jam-packed with great news and even better investments in our great province.
Investing in classrooms, care, and communities: 9 per cent for education, 10
per cent for health care, and a whopping 14 per cent increase for communities
across this great province.
Mr. Deputy Speaker, I know the NDP are
doom and gloom and are looking downtrodden, saying there’s nothing good in this
budget. They appear angry and grumpy. It’s like they think they have to do
that. Sort of like the little old lady from the old hamburger commercial,
“Where’s the beef? Where’s the beef?” Mr. Deputy Speaker, Mr. Deputy Speaker, I
can proudly say this budget is chock full of AAA prime Saskatchewan
born-and-raised beef — beef raised on our lush Saskatchewan grass, finished on
the many bushels of Saskatchewan-grown barley, beef served on a bun made from
Saskatchewan-grown wheat, butter and cheese from our world-class dairy farmers,
topped off with the best mustard in the world made from the yellow mustard
grown right here in Saskatchewan, perhaps even grown near Kipling or Corning.
All these ingredients were made possible
due to the hard work of our farmers and ranchers. Our farmers and ranchers use
the fuel and fertilizer produced right here in our great province to grow these
crops and raise livestock to feed this growing province and literally feed
people around the world.
Energy and mining companies building,
investing, creating jobs, jobs and wealth right here in Saskatchewan. New
investments in value-added ag production: hog slaughtering in Moose Jaw; canola
crushing in Yorkton; oat mills; pulp plants; and many, many more across this
great province.
Mr. Deputy Speaker, any one of these
investments would have been front page news under an NDP government, front page
news only because it was very unusual to see any kind of investment.
A
Hon. Member: — Fiction.
Mr.
D. Harrison: — Fiction. Thank you. This has changed
under our Sask Party. Investment has been welcomed
and encouraged. Businesses know Saskatchewan has a strong economy, a growing
population, and a stable government. Saskatchewan is a prime destination for
their investments. I never want to go back to the dark days of an NDP
government again.
Mr. Deputy Speaker, record investment in
classrooms, care, and communities is only possible due to a strong and growing
economy. This 2024‑25 budget has record investment without adding new
taxes or increasing taxes. A 9 per cent increase for pre-K [pre‑kindergarten]
to grade 12 classroom education. Our 27 school divisions across the province
will receive $2.2 billion in school operating funding. Record funding for
education.
This budget provides 356 million in
classroom supports, which is up over 45 million over last year and is a
significant commitment to address classroom size and complexity. This includes
funding the Teacher Innovation and Support Fund pilot and the specialized
support classrooms pilot.
Further to the record operating funding,
we are investing and building new classrooms: $216 million in capital
funding for 11 new or consolidated school projects, three major renovations, as
well as planning for nine new schools and two major renovations. Mr. Deputy
Speaker, I have one of those planned pre-K to 12 [pre‑kindergarten to
grade 12] consolidated schools in my constituency. Residents of Carlyle and the
surrounding area are very, very excited and thankful about having a new school
in town.
Mr. Deputy Speaker, record investment of
$7.6 billion in the Saskatchewan health care system: $4.7 billion for
the Saskatchewan Health Authority, an increase of 248 million;
574 million for mental health and addictions; 249 million for the
Saskatchewan Cancer Agency; $3.5 million increase for breast cancer care
and screening initiatives such as lowering the screening age to 40;
$30 million increase to support Regina and Saskatoon capacity pressures
action plan; increased funding for the health human resource action plan to
deliver on the commitment to add 250 new or enhanced permanent positions in
rural and remote locations.
Mr. Deputy Speaker, we’re investing in
Saskatchewan. Municipal revenue sharing is a one-of-a-kind,
made-in-Saskatchewan solution of stable, reliable funding for municipalities.
With this budget we have a 14 per cent increase in revenue sharing, a
$42.4 million increase for a total of over $340 million.
Mr. Deputy Speaker, our urban
municipalities truly appreciate this revenue-sharing model. SUMA [Saskatchewan
Urban Municipalities Association] president, Randy Goulden,
says:
Overall, SUMA is
very impressed with the budget. The association wants to recognize and thank
the government for increased revenue sharing with the cities, towns, villages,
resort villages, and northern municipalities that SUMA represents.
Mr. Deputy Speaker, from SARM [Saskatchewan Association of Rural Municipalities],
the president, Ray Orb, is quoted as saying:
Today’s budget
includes many priorities that our members have been asking for. Although not
perfect, we feel items in this budget go a long way to support our RMs and the people who live in rural Saskatchewan.
[15:15]
Mr. Deputy Speaker, this 2024‑25
budget, the last budget presented by the member from Humboldt-Watrous,
continues to build a stronger Saskatchewan, a budget that has record funding
increases for classrooms, care, and communities; a record budget that is only
possible due to our strong economy; record spending for education, health, and
communities to serve the growing population, the highest population in
Saskatchewan’s history.
Just announced this morning, 1,225,493
people now call Saskatchewan home. And they’re calling Saskatchewan home
because of recent investments been announced. Just to name a very few, and I’ll
start with the big one, BHP starting their mine at Jansen, investing
$18 billion right here in Saskatchewan. A world-renowned company investing
in Saskatchewan. Remarkable. Should be headlines for years to come.
Nutrien
continues to be a world leader in potash production here in the province.
Cameco is a world leader in uranium mining. They’ve been here for years and
they’ve invested billions of dollars over those years, and they continue well
into the future.
Foran
Mining starting their McIlvenna Bay copper mine — tremendous investment in our
economy right now today for copper production long into the future. Incredible,
Mr. Deputy Speaker. Just south of Regina here, Western Potash investing in
Saskatchewan. Mr. Deputy Speaker, I was at the Saskatchewan Mining Association
banquet last night, and I must say they’re very optimistic and very thankful
that they have a strong, stable government and a strong, stable economy and a
growing population to help grow their industry here in this province. We are
world leaders in mining, and we aim to get 15 per cent of the Canadian
investment into mining here in the province, and we’re well on our way.
Turning to value-added ag products, Mr.
Deputy Speaker, Louis Dreyfus canola crushing expansion. New pea protein
isolation production plant, that’s at Yorkton. Cargill just out at the Global
Transportation Hub with a canola crush. Richardson, another canola crush at
Yorkton. Donald’s Fine Foods over at Moose Jaw, a sow slaughtering plant, a
much-needed plant, Mr. Deputy Speaker. It’s very, very important for our ag
community to have that kind of plant in our backyard.
And I can go on and on, Mr. Deputy
Speaker, but all these investments are due to a strong, stable government, a
government we never had under the leadership of the NDP. And I never hope we
have that opportunity to live under an NDP government again in this province. I
don’t want to go back to that. I lived through it and I don’t want to do it
anymore. That is why I’m here. Mr. Deputy Speaker, I could on about that side
all, all day.
And the carbon tax debate, I’ve talked
long and hard about that. I know they think it’s a good thing. They keep
supporting their federal leader, Jagmeet Singh, who continues to support Justin
Trudeau, loud and clear. It’s going up on April 1st. Our Premier is asking them
to please delay, and seven other premiers have asked for the same. And the
Premier testified at a federal committee here this morning. Mr. Deputy Speaker,
it’s critical. We know it’s driving up the cost of inflation clearly across
this country. It’s driving up inflation. It’s making us less competitive.
Mr. Deputy Speaker, Canada is an
exporting nation and we export our products around the world. Saskatchewan is
the leader in exports in Canada, and we are disadvantaged severely by that NDP-led
carbon tax that keeps driving up the cost of production for our growers,
producers, manufacturers, miners, oil and energy producers. Each and every year
it’s going up and they won’t do anything about it.
Mr. Deputy Speaker, we are, led by our
Premier, testifying in front of a federal committee asking them to halt the
increase on April 1st. And there’s increases scheduled for many years to come.
And it’s just going to keep growing our inflation, the cost of food.
Mr. Deputy Speaker, we are a landlocked
province. We rely on the goods we need to come in by trucks, trains, planes,
and we also rely on those same industries to get our products to market, to
tidewater if you will. There’s a cost to that, Mr. Deputy Speaker. And
Saskatchewan people are paying that cost. And we’re tired of paying that cost
and we need to axe that carbon tax. And they need to lift their hand and demand
their federal leader halt, halt that increase. They like to yip from the
backbenches there, Mr. Deputy Speaker. They like to yip. But it is the biggest
single cause of inflation in Saskatchewan. And I won’t take it anymore from
them.
And that’s why I’m here today. And Mr.
Deputy Speaker, that’s why I’m supporting the budget presented by the Minister
of Finance, seconded by the MLA from Saskatoon Willowgrove.
I’m proud, I’m very proud to support it. And I won’t be supporting their
amendment. Thank you, Mr. Deputy Speaker.
The
Deputy Speaker: — I recognize the Deputy House Leader.
Hon.
Ms. Carr: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And it truly
is my pleasure to stand in my place today and speak to the budget brought
forward by this Saskatchewan Party government, a budget which focuses on
classrooms, care, and communities. A budget that I will be supporting. Mr.
Speaker, for me, I would like to focus on what this budget means to the
constituency of Estevan, the constituency that I am so proud and honoured to be
able to represent.
I had the opportunity to host some
people from Estevan on budget day. One of the families was Jason LeBlanc, him,
his wife Sherrill, and his daughter Gracie. It was actually the first time that
Sherrill and Gracie had ever been in the building. We spent a few hours
together, and I hope they enjoyed the day as much as I did.
It started out with them getting to the
legislature about 11 a.m. We had time to be able to tour around the building.
We travelled through the hallways looking at art, talking about the history of
this beautiful place, looking at portraits of premiers and former lieutenant
governors. After the tour I took them down to our cafeteria where they were
able to experience what our kitchen has to offer us on a daily basis.
During lunch Jason asked me, now that
you’ve been here for a while, what is your favourite part of the job and what
is your least favourite? I said, hands down my least favourite part is social
media. This is one of those things that is in our political world, and it seems
to be a necessary evil. For me it’s an opportunity to get out our government’s
message, the facts of what are actually happening — no spin, no leaving out
information — just information for my constituents to be able to look at and
digest.
But then along with that comes people
who feel it necessary to give their full, unfettered opinion, and at times they
may say things that they would likely never say to your face. Now I’m all for
free speech, but I also have an open-door policy at my constituency office.
I’ve never said no to a constituent or a stakeholder who wants to have a
conversation, whether that is better facilitated by a phone call or a
face-to-face meeting. That is what my job is. That is what all of our job is:
here is to listen to concerns of all people and take them seriously.
Then the favourite part of my job, the
answer I gave to Jason was, the ability to serve my community. And that’s where
I left it. But as I got thinking about that answer after the fact, I should’ve
definitely expanded on what I said. And it is not just the favourite part of my
job but is the most satisfying part my job, especially when we have successes
in helping people out.
When I talk about serving my community,
there is so much involved in doing that. It could be something as small as
directing a constituent to a website for some type of application that they’ve
been looking for. And if they don’t have the ability to navigate a website,
we’re more than happy to print information off and have them pick it up or have
it delivered to them.
Or it could be directing someone to the
quality-of-care coordinator when they’re having issues with a flow in the
health care system. And at times we may have to elevate these issues to a
minister’s office for them to take a look into it. For the most part, we are
able to resolve the issues that people are having.
Then after lunch it was time for the
LeBlanc family to line up, and they were fortunate enough to get a spot on the
floor of the House sitting right behind the opposition. When all was said and
done, they came back to my office and we had a chance to talk about what they
saw. And I asked Gracie specifically, because it was her first time in the
House and the first time seeing question period, and I said, what did you think
of that? And she said, I did not understand what was going on. She was talking
specifically about question period. And I said, well you’re probably not the
only one.
I took a little bit of time to explain
to them what the budget meant for our community. I believe it was a good day
for the LeBlanc family. I look forward to hosting them again, maybe on a day
that’s not quite so busy.
Mr. Speaker, I would like to focus on
things that affect my constituency directly. While there are no actual dollars
placed in this year’s budget for the MRI [magnetic resonance imaging] in
Estevan, government has provided commitments to proceed to further work with
St. Joseph’s Hospital through Emmanuel Health to move forward with their
proposal to install an MRI scanner at St. Joseph’s Hospital. Once the new MRI
scanner is installed, government is also committed to providing the ongoing
operational funding required to operate that MRI scanner.
Mr. Speaker, I’m very grateful for the
generosity and support that we have received from communities and individuals
alike, but a special thank you needs to go out to Elaine Walkom
for the $2 million that she is putting towards this project and for her
continued advocacy. She is doing this to give back to the community and region
that has given so much to her and her family. She is doing this in the memory
of her late husband, Grant. She said it is because of the success that their
business had serving southeast Saskatchewan, so she would like to give back in
his memory. The generosity of the people and the communities in the Southeast
never ceases to amaze me.
This is good news for Estevan and all of
southeast Saskatchewan. What it means is people will not have to travel to
Regina or Saskatoon to receive MRI services. It means that the wait-list will
be reduced. It means that the people of southeast Saskatchewan will have one
more set of services to be able to utilize. And as I think about the investment
being made, it is only because of a strong economy that all of this is
possible. It is because of a strong economy that the Walkoms
were able to have a successful business and be able to give back.
As well when it comes specifically to
our constituency of Estevan, we have an additional $2.5 million so the
detailed design phase of the new nursing home can be carried out. We will
continue to work closely with the committee to ensure the facility meets the
needs of our community. This is a prime example of how the Saskatchewan Party
government is helping make our communities better.
Mr. Speaker, you will also find another
$1.9 million included for planning and crushing of gravel for Highway 18
west of Estevan. This project would plan to be completed in the summer of 2025.
The length is approximately 22 kilometres, and it goes from Estevan to Outram.
And once that is completed, Highway 18 right from the Manitoba border all the
way to Highway 6 will have been resurfaced.
And then, Mr. Speaker, there is a more
holistic investments that not only my constituency but also helps the entire
province, one of them being community-based organizations. This budget gives a
3 per cent lift in operating dollars for those groups so they can continue to
serve our communities.
As well, the health care budget has been
increased by over 10 per cent. And in that increase there is a focus on getting
more individuals trained so that we can continue to work on reducing wait times
in all sections of health care. There’s also a focus on continuing to help
those with mental health and addictions issues. So on both of these initiatives
we have been making progress, but there is more work to be done. And thanks to
a strong economy, that work will continue.
We also have an 8.8 per cent increase
for our education system. This has been a big topic of late but, as you can
see, funds are being put in place to help address the issues facing education,
specifically for class size and composition. I anxiously await for a resolution
to the negotiations taking place so life can get back to normal for students
and teachers.
Agriculture is also recognized in this
budget by the fact that we are funding all business risk management programs.
As well, we have an enhanced crop insurance program for intercropping and
silage. These are programs that our producers rely on when unexpected things
happen.
And municipal revenue sharing is up over
14 per cent from last year. The city of Estevan alone will receive over
$2.5 million. This amount represents approximately 10 per cent of their
annual operating budget. Municipal revenue sharing is a formula based on PST
dollars that have been collected by the provincial government, a formula that
is stable and predictable.
[15:30]
So what this tells us is our economy is
growing. I would also note that every city, town, village, and municipality
receives this stable and predictable funding.
As well, the Ministry of Energy and
Resources is putting in some incentives to encourage more development. Right
across the province, and in Estevan, we have oil production taking place.
Saskatchewan has a growth goal of increasing oil production by 25 per cent to
600,000 barrels a day. That is why Saskatchewan is introducing a new
multilateral well drilling program to grow incremental oil production in the
province. In an article by Brian Zinchuk of Pipeline
News, he says, and I quote:
“Are multilaterals
the next big thing in oil? Saskatchewan bets heavy on it with new incentive
program.”
This is the largest
change in oil royalties in decades, as the government hopes to incentivize
activity and production. It’s a big shift for government that, for its entire
16 years in office, has said it wasn’t touching a thing when it comes to
royalties.
Let me put this
into perspective. For the several years Bill Boyd was Energy minister, he
always gave the same speech, which basically went like this: “The Premier told
me to say thank you. Thank you for the jobs, thank you for the taxes, and thank
you for the royalties and the investment. And we’re not touching a thing when
it comes to royalties.”
Usually, whenever
someone mentions royalty changes, it’s not with the intention of raising them.
This is the opposite, providing a royalty incentive, not a holiday, to get more
activity and more production going. This, folks, is swinging from the fences.
Mr. Speaker, for anyone who wants to
read the entire article, you can go to Pipeline Online. He gives a detailed
description, with pictures I might add, of exactly what a multilateral well is.
And I’m sure you’ll be able to find many other interesting articles on there.
So thank you to Brian Zinchuk for continuing to be an
advocate for the industries we have here in our province.
Mr. Speaker, I would like to briefly
touch on the debt that our province is carrying and would also like to preface
it with the fact that, because we do have a growing province, we need to be
building more hospitals, more schools, more long-term care facilities. And as
everyone is likely aware, these are things that we do not have the ability to
pay cash for. So we need to borrow. I akin it to taking out a mortgage on the
items that will get amortized over a long period of time but will take a few
years to pay off.
Now would I like to say Saskatchewan has
no debt, it’s all been paid back? You bet I would. For that to happen, it would
have to increase taxes by a large amount to be able to facilitate that. I know
I’m not on board with that, and when we are talking about affordability, that
will not help anyone. But that is likely what an NDP government would do. Of
course I’m just guessing, as they have no plan on how they would pay for
anything they suggest. But the money has to come from somewhere, Mr. Speaker.
Currently Saskatchewan’s projected net
debt as a percentage of GDP [gross domestic product] is 14 per cent. Now to put
that in perspective, it’s second lowest in Canada. The only one lower right now
is Alberta. They’re at 9.7 per cent. And an interesting fact is that not too
many years ago, Alberta had no debt. They were at zero. Now in contrast to
Ontario, who’s at 38.2 per cent; or Newfoundland, that’s at 42 per cent; I’ll
remind you we’re at 14 per cent. The country of Canada is at 46.8 per cent, Mr.
Speaker.
One more comparison I would like to make
is how things are relative. The NDP like to go on and talk about the size of
our debt. As I stated, right now ours is 14 per cent. Back in 2007, when the
NDP last had the honour to be in government, would you like to know what that
number was for them? It was 28 per cent. That is twice the actual size of what
we have today. So even though they like to compare the number of the debt, when
we talk about what is actually relative, it is a fact that their debt as a percentage
of GDP was twice the size of what it is today. So they were actually
technically carrying twice as much debt.
Once again, would I prefer to have no
debt? Of course. But it is also important to see how we stack up to other
provinces, the country of Canada, and of course the former NDP government of
Saskatchewan. There are so many other things I can highlight, but the most
important is that Saskatchewan has a strong economy, and with that comes a very
bright future.
Now just briefly back to questions that
constituents ask. This one stands out in my mind: what keeps you awake at
night? And the answer is easy. It’s the fear of disappointing someone. Now
there are a lot of things that I can do to help resolve issues, but there are
times that an issue cannot be resolved to the satisfaction of a constituent.
But, Mr. Speaker, I know that when I go to bed at night, I have done the best
job I can do and try to resolve those issues for my constituents. So while it
may keep me awake at night knowing I could not resolve the issue, I can sleep
well knowing I did the best I could do to try and resolve it.
In closing I will not be supporting the
amendment, but I will be supporting the budget brought forward by the Minister
of Finance. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
The
Deputy Speaker: — I recognize the member from
Saskatoon Nutana.
Ms.
Ritchie: — Thank you, mister deputy deputy speaker. It’s a pleasure to be on my feet entering
into debate on the 2024‑25 budget. You know, it’s a budget that is
allegedly about classrooms, care, and community. It’s an interesting tag line
for a government that, you know, in the past has been focused on build and
protect. And now we see this about-face over into sort of a space that seems
really not that credible in terms of the track record of this government, in
terms of how it has eroded funding for education in our classrooms.
We have an ongoing labour dispute with
the Saskatchewan Teachers’ Federation. It’s been going on for months. The
government side has not been bargaining in good faith and unwilling to
negotiate on class size and complexity, preferring instead to negotiate on
Twitter and on billboards and anywhere else other than at the bargaining table.
And so I’m not really sure that putting out a budget that says that you’re
focused on classrooms is really going to be believable to the people of this
province because what we’ve seen is historic underfunding.
We saw it back in 2017. We had decreases
then. In 2021 after the last election, the first thing the Sask
Party did was increase our education property taxes and reduce funding to
education. So there’s been promises made and promises broken by this government
and so when they make, you know, promises in the public domain about funding
education, they can’t be trusted. And so it’s been important that the teachers’
federation demand that these commitments be reflected in the contract instead.
So I’m not sure why the government thought it was such a bright idea to focus
on classrooms as part of its budget debate.
But then we can look at care, in the
care area, and the spending promises that have been made. And after years and
years of cutbacks, again, whether that be into social services, into the health
care realm, we’re not seeing a government that cares about the people of this
province. We’re seeing quite the opposite.
And so when you look at a government
that has basically broken our health care system and broken our social safety
net and has rolled back funding, put community-based organizations on the brink
of failing, you know, the reality really shows quite a different picture. And
so I’m not quite sure what this government thought there was to be gained by
talking about care. We’ve even heard the Premier himself say he doesn’t care,
to a chamber of commerce audience in Prince Albert when asked about his
response to the climate crisis.
And people are starting to pick up on
the disingenuous disconnect that we’re seeing between the messaging that we’re
seeing coming out from this government and the reality that they are
experiencing in their daily lives when they try to access health care, pay
their bills, and make really difficult choices about — on a monthly basis — the
bills that are going to be paid and you know, the things that they’re going to
put in their grocery cart at the grocery store.
I’ve been on the doorsteps a lot in my
constituency, in Saskatoon Nutana, and heard many stories of the difficulties
that families are facing, whether that is addressing the cost-of-living crisis,
whether that is in accessing health care services. They’re concerned about the
rates of homelessness in our communities, mental health and addictions, and
they’re not confident that this government is taking the right approach in
terms of how they are addressing these issues. What we’re seeing are major gaps
in the continuum of care for people experiencing homelessness, mental health
and addictions. And a government that is investing, you know, millions of
dollars into one end of the continuum on recovery is going to fail so many
people.
We’ve heard it from our mayors and in
councils as well. They identify mental health and addictions and housing as key
issues that they are looking to the government to solve. And I’ve been out
engaging with those leaders across the province, listening and hearing from them
in terms of what their priorities are, and where they see the need for more
care, more investment. It’s in addressing these issues that have been offloaded
to them by the provincial government and leaving them with very little means in
which to address those issues.
Now I think, you know, then we look to
whether or not this is a budget that truly does, as I say, focus on
communities. And I’ve been very fortunate to have the opportunity to get out
into many of these communities over the last couple of months, as I’ve been
undertaking engagements on my private member’s bill, a bill respecting a
comprehensive wetland conservation policy that is truly going to meet the
moment and meet the needs in terms of preserving water, preserving wetlands,
and dealing with the host of factors that we’re facing right now as a society.
And I’ll get into some of the details of that in a moment.
But I guess the thing that’s really
struck me as I’ve undertaken these consultations is that communities are
frustrated. Communities are divided. Communities are struggling to be heard,
and they’re concerned about winners and losers in terms of a policy framework
that the government is advancing, that is going to pick winners and losers. And
there’s an unfairness there. But more than that, it’s creating conflict,
conflict in communities. I had one individual say to me in a consultation
recently that we can’t have potluck dinners anymore.
[15:45]
Between issues around COVID and water, people
can’t talk, people have been threatened, and people’s livelihoods have been put
at risk. Because of an issue that has been mismanaged by this government, an
issue of ensuring that we have safe water, that we have good policy and good
governance. And I’m not seeing anything in this budget that’s going to address
those issues.
But furthermore, if we’re going to talk about how we preserve
communities, how we support communities, having good water policy is essential.
And I listened with interest to the member from Arm River yesterday talk about
a book that I have also had the great privilege to read and take some advice
from. The book is called 13 Ways to Kill Your Community. And it’s kind of
interesting because step one . . . [inaudible interjection]
. . . Yeah, well the interesting thing about this was that step one
in protecting your community is ensuring safe quality water — number one,
before anything else.
And yet as I go across the province and I talk to community members,
they tell me that water is a source of conflict, not a source of community
building. And I know, deputy deputy speaker, you’re
familiar with this issue too. You were the former minister. And I do recall
being told by you in the past that you have to worry about, you know, getting a
black eye, getting punched in the face. And I’m supposed to accept that as a
reality here in Saskatchewan that if I want to talk to my neighbour about an
issue as vital as water that I have to expect that maybe I’m going to end up a
fist fight.
And that doesn’t even make any sense to me in terms of . . .
You know, we live in a rule-based society and the people of this province
expect us to be leaders, to put forward governance structures that are going to
lead towards resolutions of conflicts — not their escalation but their resolution.
And we had a provincial audit report going back to 2018 that identified
the lack of policy around wetland conservation as a gap. And yet six years on,
you know, we still don’t have a policy. And that at a time when, you know,
we’re seeing increasing concerns about water on the
landscape.
We had a budget announcement of
$1.15 billion towards an irrigation project for the Westside project. That
was after the election promise that came out before the 2020 election, where
they estimated $3 billion to expand irrigation in three phases. They went
off afterwards and had some engineering analysis, some financial analysis
undertaken, and now we see costs, you know, looking like they’ve tripled where
I’ve seen only one phase of that project go forward at a cost of $1.15 billion.
We see no matching money from the federal government, and now they’re looking
for private producers and investors to help partner on that.
Fine, so who benefits from that? Like is
that an equitable . . . There’s many questions. There’s many
questions about the soundness of that major project undertaken. We still
haven’t seen the engineering reports, the financial analysis. The government is
holding on. They’re not finalizing the reports. I, as a water critic, can’t
even take a look at those reports because they haven’t been tabled.
And yet there are serious questions
about a commitment that’s being made in this budget towards funding an
irrigation project where the numbers haven’t been scrutinized. And I think as
members of this legislature that we all have the right to review and scrutinize
the reports before we make such a significant investment.
A lot of communities are asking
questions, a lot of individuals are asking questions about water supply.
They’re asking questions about the ongoing drought, how that is also impacting
our provincial budget, how that’s impacting the forecasts in terms of
production from agriculture.
And so when we look at all these
pressures, they ultimately are budgetary pressures on a budget that’s making
very optimistic projections in terms of how much money is coming in and how
much money is going to have to be spent out. Interestingly enough, that’s
during an election year. What a coincidence. A rosy budget that makes
optimistic productions and then, I mean it even, you know, looks out in terms
of the following years in terms of very sluggish economic growth, increasing
rates of unemployment. We even see corporate tax revenues falling by half a
billion dollars and, you know, grave concerns. I mean last year a
$1.5 billion, you know, off the mark. And what in this budget gives anyone
confidence that we’re actually going to be able to find ourself in the position
that is being projected?
And despite all of that, there’s been no
affordability relief for Saskatchewan people. No affordability relief. And we
continue to have records being broken in terms of the social indicators across
our province, so many indicators where we’re worst in the nation. And we are
going to be seeing more homelessness, more child poverty, longer wait-lists for
health services, and ongoing lack of access to family doctors. One in six
Saskatchewan residents does not have a family doctor. We see a — shockingly —
reduction in life expectancy greater than anywhere else in the country, as well
as the worst crime levels.
Certainly we are seeing in many respects
that people are struggling. People are not better off. People are experiencing
serious harms, and there’s nothing in this budget to point to added relief,
either on their bottom line or in terms of better access to services.
And as we’ve been talking to people
across this province, you know, we’ve listened to front-line workers. We hear
they have the solutions. This government won’t listen to them. They turn around
instead and invest $14 million in a marshals service that hasn’t added a
single officer to fight crime, and it won’t until 2026. That money would be
better spent being redirected toward the existing police services that exist in
this province, not creating another whole layer of bureaucracy and an added
cost. It’s waste and mismanagement.
We see a $12 million advertising
campaign in airports and in other provinces and countries. I mean, how does
that contribute to the interests of the province? It doesn’t. We see an
$11 million settlement with a local business over the government’s actions
in Wascana Park. I could go on and on. This
government has been wasting money, money that could be spent on providing
affordability relief to Saskatchewan residents who are struggling to put food
on the table and making difficult decisions about whether to keep the lights on
or pay for Johnny’s runners for the school year.
It’s a budget that provides a rosy
forecast based on hope, but certainly the people of this province have lost
faith in this government to provide any hope for the future. And you know,
people are ready for change. And we’re ready to deliver on this side of the
House.
And we’ll be happy to share our
solutions and our platform when the time is ready, based on what we’re hearing
from front-line workers and people who are, you know, full of hope and optimism
for the future and know how to truly make Saskatchewan a greater province, one
that meets the needs of all people in ways that are compassionate and caring
and don’t make the hard kinds of trade-offs that we’ve seen from this
government that’s seen social metrics plummet across the piece. And we’re ready
to do that. We look forward to that opportunity.
I think my time is almost up, mister
deputy deputy speaker, but before I end, I want to
take a moment to thank my constituency assistant Kerry Schaefer and alternate
CA McGinnis Reeve for all of their help and support in my office, responding to
constituency’s concerns, helping me with the stakeholders and keeping the
office running in shipshape throughout the year.
I want to thank my family, as so many
have already done here today and in these budget responses. Of course none of
us serve alone, and I’m so grateful for their support as I do this work.
I want to make a special mention of my
mother, Eleanor Ritchie. She’s having a 90th birthday this year. We’re really
excited about the opportunity to celebrate her life, and she’s certainly been
an inspiration for me. And we’ll be celebrating that in June, and I hope to get
her here as a guest in the Assembly before we break in the springtime. And I
just want to thank her for being such a great mother and raising us all so
well, and I look forward to celebrating her birthday later this spring.
I also want to thank my constituency
executive and all the work that they do to ensure that we’re ready for that
next election, that, you know, we continue to have outreach going on throughout
the year, and just all the various ways that they support me in the work that I
do here, providing lots of good feedback and advice in terms of policy areas as
well. I couldn’t do this work without them either.
And so with that, I’ll wrap up my
remarks. I will not be voting in favour of the budget. I will be instead
supporting the amendment put forward by the member for Regina Rosemont and
seconded by the member for Regina Elphinstone-Centre.
The
Deputy Speaker: — I recognize the member from Regina
Gardiner Park.
[16:00]
Hon.
Mr. Makowsky: — Thank you very
much, Mr. Speaker. Always a pleasure and honour to rise up in the Assembly and
say a few words. I thank the Whip for the chance. It’s getting late in the
speaking order here, but a chance to say a few words on behalf of my family, my
constituents, and the folks that work hard every day here in Saskatchewan
particularly.
Along with myself, I have a lot of
people I get to work with that do, like I said, yeoman’s work. They’re very
dedicated and special people, particularly in the minister’s office here, and
of course being the Minister of Social Services. There is some great work being
done.
It is often very challenging work, and
the folks in the political office here at the legislature, the 1,900 or so
employees at the Ministry of Social Services in different areas, helping the
most vulnerable people in Saskatchewan. And we thank them for their often very
difficult, often overlooked work that is so, so important, and again I thank
them, and thank them that we’re all working together to make things a little
bit better in our province.
If I have time, I’ll talk a little bit
more about the budgetary expenditure in the Ministry of Social Services. And I
almost forgot — on the constituency side as well there’s folks that do great
work right across the province in so many different offices, helping people
that may need some help or some advice and with casework or whatever it may be,
so a lot of that goes on. And thanks to all those, including the folks I work
with. So thanks so much for them.
It’s a pleasure to be able to represent
an area of Regina and have been able to do that for the next 12 years, Mr.
Speaker. Hope to be able to do that again past the fall. Of course there’s an
election coming up. Let my name stand, but I know that that will be another
challenge I certainly look forward to, Mr. Speaker. I know Regina is one of the
most affordable places, larger centres in our entire country, that is very
affordable, relatively speaking, understanding there are challenges out there.
I understand that. I hear from constituents and certainly in the file that I am
able to serve in, I hear that quite a bit. But again, no new taxes in this
budget, Mr. Speaker, helps on that affordability side.
And then maybe later on I’ll talk about
a few more measures that we were able to bring forward. But in terms of, and
it’s right in the budget documents, in terms of affordability, Mr. Speaker
. . . and we’re hearing a lot of that, and I understand that. But on
the tax side, Mr. Speaker, on the utilities side, on the housing side, Mr.
Speaker, we’re in decent shape here in Saskatchewan.
So appreciate representing the, being an
MLA in Regina. And speaking of that, I know I’m roughly 10, 15 minutes to get
home each and every day. And as a Regina member, obviously we get to go home
every evening — well not every evening, but it’s more of a normal situation
than many of the members that serve. And I think I don’t take enough time to
think about that. I know I’m on the road a little bit here and there, Mr.
Speaker, but these members are . . . many members are on the road all
the time.
And at this point I’d like to thank all
the members that aren’t running again and all the amazing work that they’ve
done on behalf of the people of the province. They’re really good people, each and
every one of them, just salt-of-the-earth folks that want to give back to their
community, and that’s been my experience. And I had a great time getting to
know them a little bit, having conversations about what’s going on in their
area of Saskatchewan.
And thank you to their families for
their sacrifice as well. I know what that challenge can be. I’m sure
. . . again I don’t fully know exactly about that, but very
privileged to be able to be so close to home and be a part of kids’ sports and being
able to coach and do all those sorts of things. But the sacrifice that some of
our members who have been in government, or been serving rather for 25 years —
and some record holders even for the amount of times they’ve . . .
length of time they’ve either been serving or been in executive government. And
we thank them for that and learn so much from each of those folks. So I wish
them certainly the best and look forward to a chance to say hi to them when
we’re, either they or myself are not in this business anymore.
But, Mr. Speaker, I thought I’d talk a
bit about my family just real quick, Mr. Speaker. A few minutes ago probably
Tami got home. Just put in a shift at 811 HealthLine.
She mentioned to me, we want to ensure that right in the budget speech 811 HealthLine was mentioned, and the support that the Minister
of Health brought forward to help that particular entity within the SHA
[Saskatchewan Health Authority] who do outstanding work to help not have as
many folks show up at emergency, being able to talk to a health care
professional to hopefully diagnose and help make decisions as to where is the
best place to access services in our province.
So she’s been doing that for many years.
And speaking of many years, Mr. Speaker, in a matter of days we’ll be able to
celebrate our 25th anniversary, Mr. Speaker. The time has just clicked by so
quickly, but obviously that’s an important day, and looking forward to that.
My three boys, one is still in high
school. I can’t remember if I got a chance to mention, but I’ve got to get on
the record permanently, Mr. Speaker. I can’t remember when the football season
ended last fall and if I got a chance to speak and mention it, so I’m going to
do it here just to make sure. Able to coach. And my youngest son this time was on
a championship, provincial championship football team, Mr. Speaker. And so the
Miller Marauders were able to squeak out a victory up at SMF [Saskatoon Minor Football] Field late
last fall for the 6A provincial championship, third
year in a row.
And so that was a lot of fun, able to
coach the O-line [offensive line] with that great group of kids. Had a lot of
fun and look forward to the upcoming season where we will have some fun again,
Mr. Speaker. My oldest son will be in grade 12 so that’s again . . .
Speaking of time clicking by, I’ll watch the clock here. I better.
And the other area I was going to
. . . My two older guys, they’re at the U of R [University of Regina]
and both with the U of R Rams program, so a busy fall. It’s always busy in our family
and look forward to that. And of course I mentioned the upcoming campaign —
looking forward to that challenge as well.
Speaking of the U of R, Mr. Speaker, in
terms of what’s in the budget, my colleague just across the aisle here, the
Minister of Advanced Education . . . I was just at an event a couple
of days ago with him where he talked about where the provincial government was
able to . . . On top of the four-year funding agreement that the
Ministry of Advanced Ed had with the post-secondary sector, there was a signing
ceremony that the minister was able to bring a bit of a top-up, a
$12 million top-up to that four-year funding agreement, Mr. Speaker. So
again with his work that was a really good announcement and a very much
appreciated part of this budget that was being announced. So that is good news
for that very important sector.
I
should note also that next year there’s some pretty important anniversaries,
and it just kind of coincides with some of the meetings I had or events I’ve
gone to. That one, the U of R, 50 years old next year, as well as in ’25 the U
of R is hosting the Vanier Cup. The Vanier Cup is coming to Regina and so look
forward to that next fall. The 60th anniversary of the Vanier Cup is going to
be celebrated along with the 50th year at the U of R, so very much looking
forward to that. We’ll see how that goes. But congratulations to the University
of Regina, the Rams and the Cougars and all that — great programs. And they’re
taking on a big deal, and great to have those events here in the Queen City,
Mr. Speaker.
Another event I was able to go to
. . . And I told my seatmate here, the Minister of Agriculture. I’d
mentioned the cattlemen were here for a bit of a gathering to talk about things
that are important to their industry. I certainly am not even close to an
expert in that area but had some great conversations about what their
priorities are, how they run their businesses.
It’s always great to engage in those
things. You learn so much and you meet a lot of great people, and we have a lot
of great people in the ag sector and the cattle sector. And I wish them all the
best this time of year, and hopefully rain is part of their very near future
and into the summer. So I had a great situation with that.
The president certainly had some
interesting things to say about the minister’s work, but also the work being
done internationally and how important that is to that agriculture sector and
how that opens doors. I know there was a few members opposite there. They must
have felt a little sheepish based on what was presented there by the
cattlemen’s association and how they’re not interested in any international
outreach and expanding our markets, Mr. Speaker. But we’re going to continue to
do that, and that’s again part of this budget, Mr. Speaker.
I was able to attend an event. I was
invited to another anniversary situation here. It’s a trend going. SaskAbilities had a bit of an announcement on what they’re
doing in terms of connecting disabled people with being able to work, to get a
job and do what they can to the best of their ability. And that is helped by
the Ministry of Immigration and Career Training. But the amazing work by SaskAbilities in our communities for the past 75 years.
Next year’s going to be 75 years of helping so many vulnerable people in our
communities.
And they have a lot to offer, Mr.
Speaker. Of course SaskAbilities does, but so many
citizens out there, and it’s great to see that they’re making those important
connections in our communities every day. And just love that work and what’s
happening there. So congratulations to that organization, and what a great
group. I just think that those type of organizations just epitomize
Saskatchewan. They care so much. They’re so ingrained, involved in their
communities, and they’re just good, good people that want to help out. And so
that is outstanding to see that work.
I had an opportunity to open another
group home here recently in Regina, Mr. Speaker, Chip and Dale Homes who do
wonderful work. It’s a day program space that they had renovated with some
money from the Ministry of Social Services, Mr. Speaker. I could certainly go
on and on with those types of things, and it’s an honour to be able to attend
those events and, like I said, learn.
Just in terms of the Ministry of Social
Services, the area I’m honoured to serve in, Mr. Speaker, there are a few
highlights I’d like to mention, get on the record. And I know many members have
talked about this. They did a great job in their speeches in the House.
Autism funding, that is going to be
increased by $4 million in this particular budget. There is certainly a
need out there. And this is a program our government brought forward to have
individualized funding for families to be able to decide what’s best for their
child that is . . . that has some . . . They have some
needs out there, is what I was trying to say, Mr. Speaker. And this is funding
that they can decide what is best for their child in this particular situation.
There’s $17 million to help those
who are trying to choose work in a low-income area. Low-income families, there
is costs to going to work. We understand that, Mr. Speaker, and so we’re able
to come up with 17 million additional dollars to help with those
challenges for folks who qualify.
We’ll be able to help them either stay
off income assistance or move off income assistance with some support, with a
cash or grant amount each and every month to help with those costs, Mr.
Speaker, but also at the same time be able to have those families stay on supplementary
health benefits, which we know was a bit of a gap to be able to come off of
those core income assistance programs. So we’ll monitor that, and hopefully
there is uptake and we’re able to help people be able to stay employed, Mr.
Speaker.
The
personal care home benefit goes up again for the second year in a row. This is
a subsidy for low-income seniors to be able to stay in private care homes, Mr.
Speaker. So there is, again, on top of the $1.5 billion we’re spending
this year, 112 million increase in the Ministry of Social Services budget.
There’s
increases to the core income assistance programs, SIS [Saskatchewan income
support], and SAID [Saskatchewan assured income for disabilities]. That has
increased the last three years that I’ve had the pleasure to serve as the
minister, Mr. Speaker. So in the SIS program, the individuals on that program
. . . meant to be, again, a temporary program, and we hope that the
employment incentive program will help ensure that is a temporary program for
individuals that are having a bit of a challenge for a period of time.
[16:15]
But that has increased again for the
third year in a row. A 26 per cent increase has been put forward in the last
five years or so. Since about the summer of 2019 when the SIS program came
online, there’s been a 26 per cent increase to those benefits for those
individuals who need a little bit of help out there, Mr. Speaker — again meant
to be an income of last resort, and it’s part of that social safety net that we
have in our province, Mr. Speaker.
Many of the programs I just mentioned
are new programs. There was no distinction under the previous government about
those who have permanent disabilities and those who are temporarily on income
assistance, Mr. Speaker. There was no personal care home benefit. There was no
seniors’ income plan under the NDP. There was no individualized funding for
autism, Mr. Speaker. There was no funding for individuals trying to join the
workforce, Mr. Speaker. And so these are all new programs to this government
but, Mr. Speaker, I wanted to point out that there was absolutely none of these
programs under the members opposite.
Some of the other things, Mr. Speaker,
we were able to invest in, just real quickly. We know how important Mobile
Crisis is to the most vulnerable in our province, Mr. Speaker. Able to come up
with a $500,000 increase, again listening and working with our stakeholders.
That was an important initiative we were able to come up with, Mr. Speaker.
The FASD [fetal
alcohol spectrum disorder] network got some funding to have . . .
They do great work in prevention services in our province. And they are able to
do some more outreach with a cash injection on top of what we normally do,
again, but this is new money within this budget.
In this budget there is again funding
for mobile outreach workers on the income assistance side of our ministry, Mr.
Speaker. That has been well received by many of our community-based
organizations. And this is about having workers out in the field, meeting
people where they are and helping them within our communities. So that has
been, like I said, well received within the sector, the income assistance area.
That has been doubled with this budget, Mr. Speaker, so we’re going to have
more people out in our community on a daily basis and helping people wherever
those caseworkers might find them.
And again, at the top I thanked the
wonderful workers within the Ministry of Social Services. I’m going to do it
again. They do great work.
Increased funding on top of the funding
from last budget for trusteeship, Mr. Speaker. And this is a program where we
partner with third parties to be able to deliver money, help, to be able to
have individuals learn about budgeting and using their funds to the best use
possible, and even have trustees be able to make those payments directly to
whoever it may be. And that program has seen some success. We want to expand
that. We’re hearing, Mr. Speaker, about individuals having a difficult time
paying bills or being able to, you know, budget and work on those type of
things, Mr. Speaker. So this is almost as much educational as physically doing
some of that work.
So I could certainly talk more and more
about some of the things we’re able to do. One last thing, Mr. Speaker, a provision
for ID [identification]. We’re hearing from the sector, from people on the
front line that individuals experiencing homelessness not being able to access
supports. One of those things is identification. Whether it gets stolen or it
gets lost, people who are having challenges out there, ID is a thing. So this
provides funding to be able to pay for ID for those on the SIS program.
Mr. Speaker, all of these supports are
only available and sustainable into the long term because of our strong and
growing economy. It simply can’t happen, or it can’t happen for very long. So I
think the Minister of Finance did a great job balancing the need out there with
the reality that we have to find a way to pay for it, Mr. Speaker, and have it
sustainable going into the future.
Really quickly, some of the capital
projects in Regina, I want to mention them once again. The last thing I’ll say,
Mr. Speaker, General Hospital parkade, room for over
1,000 stalls. The urgent care centre going up on North Albert, Mr. Speaker — been
there several times. It’s looking great and, my understanding from the Minister
of Health, opening very soon. Long-term care beds procurement is under way here
in Regina. Regina North school, a joint-use school combining four schools here
in our community. A French school, Mr. Speaker. Harbour Landing School.
Planning for a joint-use elementary school in east Regina, which is going to be
of very interest to my constituents, as well as preplanning for a southeast
joint-use high school, Mr. Speaker.
The Minister of Finance has paid off in
recent years two and a half billion dollars of operating debt, second-best
debt-to-GDP ratio in the nation of Canada. Our finances are strong, and that’s
why with a strong economy we’re able to invest in all of the things.
I could have talked for way longer, but
I’ve taken enough time, Mr. Speaker. The Whip has given me a bit of an eye over
here, Mr. Speaker.
But this budget allows us to work on our
priority areas and invest in people in our province.
So, Mr. Speaker, thanks for the
opportunity, to my constituents once again for being here. Thanks to my family.
Thanks to all the people who work in the social services area. What would we do
without you?
Mr. Speaker, I’m going to be supporting
the budget.
The
Deputy Speaker: — I recognize the member from Yorkton.
Mr.
Ottenbreit: — Thank you, Mr. Deputy Speaker. It’s
an honour to join in to what will be my 17th I believe and my last budget
debate of my political career. And it’s been an honour to serve in this Assembly
since 2007. I sought nomination in 2004, elected in . . . nominated
in 2005, and elected in ’07. It’s been a fairly long career, not as long as
some of my colleagues who I appreciate so much, but it has truly been an
honour, Mr. Deputy Speaker.
As is customary, I’m not going to go
into much detail on the family and things and even some of my colleagues. I’m
going to save that for my final speech that’ll be coming in a few weeks from
now. But again, to acknowledge the support and the love of family is first and
foremost and why we’re able to serve in this place.
And a reason that I’m . . .
partly why I’m not going to seek re-election came to me last night when I had
to miss my granddaughter’s 9th birthday. And it’s not a huge deal, but for us,
we’re a tight family and it was enjoyable to watch the family’s celebrations
from afar. But number 10, I’ll be there for Wynn.
Again, staff, whether it’s Lauretta and
Rachelle back at home or the staff that supports all of us here whether through
the ministers’ offices, the caucus offices, or Executive Council, whatever the
case might be, Mr. Deputy Speaker, they’re just so appreciated. And of course,
all members of one team, one family that works together to serve the people of
this province.
My executive back home, which may be
changing a little bit in the next little while, there’s a new nominated
candidate for Yorkton that will be running in the election this year. So I’m
just so appreciative of the executive I’ve had, to see who’s staying, see who’s
going to be coming on, and to see that team build for the next election. And of
course, all the constituents that have placed me here over the years.
When I first ran in ’07, I made a
commitment to my family and local people, four terms, that was my cap. In fact,
the former deputy premier, a friend of mine to this day, Clay Serby, kind of confided in me that, you know, after four
terms even some of his strong supporters were getting tired of him. Before I
get to that point, Mr. Deputy Speaker, it’s time to go on to whatever the Lord
has for me next.
You know, and saying that, looking at
some of the results that Clay went through over those four terms, we’ve been
blessed in Yorkton — 59 per cent in my first election, 71, 73, final election,
75, Mr. Deputy Speaker. So I’m going to get out before it maybe dips a little
bit. You know, that’s great.
And you know, the three people that put
their names forward to fill my position, I’m so appreciative of them. Kaitlyn Kitzan, a young lady with a lot political knowledge,
agriculture business background, put in a heck of a challenge. Darcy Zaharia, I’ve known for most of my life in Yorkton, a city
councillor and a football coach and very community-minded. You know, he was a
very good adversary.
David Chan, a young man, 42 years old.
First generation Chinese gentleman with a young family, two girls. I’m not
spoiling, I don’t think, anything by saying he’s got one on the way as well,
probably only a couple months before the election. But he’s going to be a great
representative who I believe will win the next election and will be sitting on
this floor on this side of the House when that does happen.
You know, Mr. Deputy Speaker, before I
get into the throes of the budget, you know, a few comments on some of the
things I’ve heard across the floor. And I appreciate the input of the
opposition members. You know, a lot of it is pretty good. Some of it, I really
scratch my head. But you know, over and over, I’ve heard them refer to this as
an election budget, election budget. All the other input I’ve seen from
business input or media input or community leaders, they were kind of shocked.
They said, you know, it’s kind of steady as she goes, pretty almost boring. You
know, it’s what you wouldn’t expect in an election-year budget.
Granted, there’s some significant
increases in specific areas, but as my colleagues have pointed out, that’s for
specific reasons. A strong economy is what we have. We were able to put
together a $20 billion budget this year to build on classrooms and care in
our health care community and of course in our communities, Mr. Deputy Speaker.
Specifically, our revenue sharing is up huge amounts, the highest it’s ever
been. Again, revenue sharing, something that was non-existent under the members
opposite when they formed government. But again a very common-sense budget and
a very steady-as-she-goes budget is what I’ve heard.
Quite often I hear the members
. . . [inaudible] . . . we’re back-patting. Well I have
never seen anybody on this side of the House back-pat. You know, they ask, what
have you done? What have you done? You mention what you’ve done, then they turn
it back and now you’re patting your backs. We’re reminding the people of this
province what’s happened under the leadership of Premier Wall and now the
current Premier. And, Mr. Deputy Speaker, you have to continue to remind
people.
If they listened to the members
opposite, and you know, some of the stuff that the media report that the
members opposite are saying, they would not have the whole story, Mr. Deputy
Speaker. So we have to continue to remind people what it was like in the dark
days of the NDP, what it’s been like the last 16 years under this government,
and what they can look forward into the future with a strong economy, and
again, investments in our province through classrooms, care, and communities,
Mr. Deputy Speaker.
Again I’m going to forgo some of the
acknowledgements of my retiring members, my current members, although I’d like
to take a few shots. Maybe the member for Kindersley. Melville-Saltcoats wasn’t
bad. Melfort was okay. Moosomin, he’s on the edge, but I’ll leave him alone
till maybe towards the end of this session.
You know, and some of the comments from
the members opposite. You know, everything’s fine, everything’s . . .
We’re not saying everything’s fine, Mr. Deputy Speaker. We’re saying there’s
definite challenges. We’re up to the task of addressing those challenges. This
budget is specifically pointing to those areas that we’re going to focus on to
address those challenges.
But for goodness’ sake, Mr. Deputy
Speaker, you have to acknowledge where things are good, if things are going in
the right direction. The glass isn’t always half empty. The glass can be half
full from time to time, and I think it’s important for our own mental health,
for the mental health and the knowledge of the people of this province,
acknowledge the good stuff. Acknowledge and build on that. Protect what has
been built, but also recognize where there are challenges and focus on those
challenges. And I think this government, directly to the point, has over the
last 16 years addressed those challenges in pretty significant ways.
So again, mister . . .
[inaudible interjection] . . . Thanks, buddy. Fred didn’t tackle me
down yet. Again, Mr. Deputy Speaker, a large budget with significant
investments on behalf of the people of the classroom and many different areas.
You know, I’m just going to just kind of
breeze over some of the stuff that is really going to impact our home community
of Yorkton. Fourteen per cent increase in revenue sharing, again something
non-existent under the NDP. We’re seeing significant . . . Because of
that strong economy that enables us to build on our investments in classrooms
and care and communities, Mr. Deputy Speaker, we see investments in Yorkton
that have never been seen in the past.
You know, Harvest Meats, a stalwart in
the area, is expanding quietly over time. You see their products everywhere.
You look at Grain Millers, quietly doubled in size. Richardson Oilseed’s canola
crushing has doubled in size and added other services. You look at Louis Dreyfus
has doubled in size, and now they’re adding a half-a-billion-dollar
pea-processing plant. Our government has significantly invested to make sure
that that growth continues, that goes on, the investment continues in our
province and my home community.
But also in infrastructure, the Minister
of Highways, previous and this one, has addressed a lot of the infrastructure
needs around Yorkton. There’s more to do. We’ve invested through the rural
integrated roads for growth program on Grain Millers road that has some
challenges, but we’re looking at addressing that with the partnership of the RM
[rural municipality] and the city in the future. You know, we look at the
construction, the renovations that have happened in our schools and in so many
different areas, Mr. Deputy Speaker.
You know, I’m not going to touch on too
many of the other specific areas that my colleagues did, but again looking at
some of the investments around the province that impact people locally.
As many know, I’m a cancer survivor. I
currently have a brother that’s going through a significant battle. And you
know, a small thing to some but significant to the Cancer Agency and to me and
to people that are affected, colleagues that have been affected, Mr. Deputy
Speaker. That increase, quite a large increase to the Cancer Agency, is another
example that we’re focusing on care to support the people of this area.
[16:30]
I looked at the education funding, the
significant increase that’s going to contribute to Good Spirit School Division,
the Roman Catholic school division, Mr. Deputy Speaker — definite benefit. Some
of the general investments in health care, we know that the region is talking
about bringing orthopedics back to Yorkton, expanding
services.
And one thing before I do leave my feet,
Mr. Deputy Speaker, is another million-dollar investment through this Finance
minister who I just so much appreciate and respect. I’ve built a friendship.
I’ve worked with her in many different files over the years. Another million dollars
for planning and continuing the project in Yorkton, so I look forward to that
going ahead in the future, Mr. Deputy Speaker.
You know, I’m just going to close my
comments here pretty quickly. You know, we have to really, again, realize what
the history was like under the NDP. I grew a family. I ran a business under the
former NDP years of influence over this province, and I can tell you it was not
an easy task. When all of my friends were leaving the province, I stayed. I ran
my business, grew my family.
But seeing how they flourished over the
last 16 years under this government, how businesses have flourished, how my
former business has flourished, you know, we’ve got to focus on that. We’ve got
to not be dragged back by the NDP. We can’t allow them to take us back to those
dark days, crash our economy. We’ve got to continue to focus on the plan that
was put in place by our former premier Wall.
The next plan that was put in place by
this current Premier, the best, the most, I would argue, maybe second on the
polls right now, but the second-most popular Premier in the province. The
speech I saw him do at SARM, the speech I saw him do
or the presentation I saw him do on committee a good part of this morning, Mr.
Deputy Speaker, makes me proud to be involved with this party, with this group
of individuals, friends and family, and this Premier, Mr. Deputy Speaker.
So I will be supporting this budget. I
will not be supporting the amendment. And I look forward to the continued time
of the last few weeks I have in this House, the few months I have serving the
people of Yorkton, and I look forward to the next Sask
Party government. As was conceded, I think, by the member for Saskatoon Centre
time and time again in her speech, talking about “when those members come back
and the next budget they present.”
So I’m really, really hopeful that her
prophetic vision takes flight and we do see that strong Saskatchewan Party
representation come back in the end of 2024 and continue for many years to
come. Thank you, Mr. Deputy Speaker.
The
Deputy Speaker: — I recognize the member from The
Battlefords.
Hon.
Mr. Cockrill: — Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It’s a
pleasure to be on my feet today to respond to the 2024‑2025 budget, Mr.
Speaker. You know, I just want to begin my comments today just with a few thank
yous for people who play a very key role in my role
as an MLA. And you know, obviously first of all I’d just like to thank the
constituents of The Battlefords, the constituents who sent me here in 2020, and
really the reason that I serve every day and get up and get excited about
coming to work.
You know, I didn’t grow up in my
community, Mr. Speaker, but it didn’t take me very long after moving to my
community to realize that we’ve got a pretty special place and a special region
of the province, Mr. Speaker. And I have always defended and stood up for The
Battlefords, and you know, I continue to do so. And I hope that I have the
honour of continuing to do that as long as I have the privilege of serving as
an MLA.
Mr. Speaker, I’d also like to thank my
family. And you know, when I was elected in 2020, it was just my wife and I.
And since then we’ve added one to that, part of the Saskatchewan growth plan.
And you know, Mr. Speaker, that little guy, Bennett, he was here the other day
last week clapping and banging his hands on the bench up in the gallery. Mr.
Speaker, he’s really the highlight of our lives every day, and watching him
learn and grow is quite something. And so we are, Meagan and I are incredibly
blessed to have Bennett in our lives.
You know, and I’ll just say in my
current role I’ve certainly been in the spotlight more in the last several
months. And you know, I’ll just say, you know, the work that we do here as MLAs
and as ministers of the Crown, it is important, but it doesn’t come without
some cost and sacrifice to our families. And you know, I would say that Meagan
has been absolutely steadfast over my whole time as an MLA but certainly over
the last several months. And I know that there’s probably many days in the last
year that have been harder on her than . . . It’s been harder on her
than it has been on me many days, so I really appreciate, really appreciate
Meagan for the role that she plays in my life.
You know, and I would just say too
beyond Meagan, I know that, you know, my family, my extended family and her
extended family play a very large and generous role in terms of being our
support network, and I want to thank those folks as well.
And you know, I want to thank every one
of those people in North Battleford and here at the legislature in Regina who
have been responding to people, to calls, to emails — sometimes less than
cordial ones — really with a high degree of patience and grace. And you know,
obviously, I mean it’s my name on the door, it’s my name on the bottom of the
email, but at the end of the day these folks play a very significant role in
the work that I do. And I thank them for that.
You know, I’d also like to just thank
the ministry officials that I’ve had the opportunity to work with. I mean, my
time serving as minister of Highways and minister responsible for Saskatchewan
Water Security Agency, I worked with some fantastic people in that Crown
corporation and that ministry.
And you know, it’s funny. You run into
these folks that you’ve had the opportunity to work with. You run into them at
the SARM convention or at other events, and you know,
you really grow in respect for the work that they do each and every day.
And I’ll say the people that I get to
work with in the Ministry of Education have been absolutely fantastic in my
time, and I’m sure the former minister can speak to that as well. But really,
you know, helping me navigate some interesting times in the sector and then
also again supporting our different sector partners.
You know, I know many of the members who
have spoken have talked about the folks in our caucus that are not seeking
re-election. And again, it took me a few . . . I had to go through
the list. Just wanted to make sure, you know. I checked it twice, thrice. You
know, Regina Northeast, Canora-Pelly, Carrot River Valley, Arm River,
Weyburn-Big Muddy, Saskatoon Southeast, Saskatoon Northwest, Indian
Head-Milestone, Humboldt-Watrous, Kindersley, Batoche, Yorkton. And Biggar-Sask Valley, of course, Mr. Speaker.
You know, and I’ll just say I spoke
about the member from Arm River when I had an opportunity to reply to the
Throne Speech in the fall. But you know what’s amazing? I look at that list and
I think I have had the opportunity to tour pretty much every constituency, at
least every rural constituency for sure, with those members. And I think about,
you know, the member from Canora-Pelly and I, we went on a bus tour from the
town of Arran, and we met with a whole bunch of rural municipalities and toured
all around there.
I remember I picked up the member from
Batoche in Wakaw one day at the gas station. Him and I went for a little drive
down Highway 225. We went to Bellevue and we went over to the Batoche National
Historic Site and then south back. And I think back it’s Highway 312 that comes
back into Wakaw. And you know, that member from Batoche is just a wealth of
knowledge about the history of this province. You know, barely got
. . . I drive a little fast sometimes, Mr. Speaker, but I slowed down
a little bit because I was missing so many things that he was pointing out
along the way. And I learned a lot about his part of the province just in those
few hours with that member from Batoche.
And I think that is, you know, the gift
that those members — and really I’d say all the members on our side — have
given me as an MLA. And again, I mentioned earlier I didn’t grow up in this
province. I didn’t grow up in my community. So as somebody who’s relatively new
to Saskatchewan, to receive the gift of all these people showing me their home
communities, their constituencies, what’s special, what gets them excited about
serving as the MLA for their respective constituencies, that’s been a real gift
for me. That has been an incredible gift to learn about the province in that
way. And really that’s really the highlight, I would say, of my work.
You know, I’ll just speak specifically
about I’ve had the opportunity previously to serve on treasury board. And so
I’ve had first-hand the opportunity to really see . . . There’s a few
folks that aren’t running again that I had the opportunity to serve on treasury
board with: the member from Indian Head-Milestone, the member from Kindersley,
and of course the Deputy Premier and the member from Humboldt-Watrous.
The member from Humboldt-Watrous is
absolutely an incredible servant to this province. You know, the encyclopedic knowledge of different ministries, you know,
when they come to treasury board and go through that budget development
process, it is remarkable what that woman has retained and what she has
learned. And wow, it’s something that we’re going to certainly miss as a caucus
and as a cabinet. But boy, I have tried to glean as much knowledge out of her
as I can, certainly over the last few years and last several months.
The same is true for the member from
Indian Head-Milestone, somebody who was elected the same time as the Deputy
Premier in 1999 and has served in several different ministries. And the
absolutely impressive recall ability of these folks to think back to something
that happened in 2004 and kind of go verbatim on what happened in 2004 or 2008.
It’s been, I would say for the other members that were elected last time, it’s
been a real educational opportunity — right? — to learn from these folks.
Also, you know, the member from
Kindersley . . . It’s interesting. You know, I was a new MLA and I
was given the amazing privilege of serving on treasury board. And so I ended up
spending a lot of time with the member from Kindersley in those first few
years. I don’t know if that was a good thing or a bad thing.
But you know what? I was thinking about
it. I don’t know, I don’t know if the member plays more of a father figure or a
brother figure or just, you know, the friend who chirps you kind of all the
time role. But I’m sure glad that I got to meet this fine gentleman, and
looking forward to continuing our friendship in years going forward.
You know, a thank you to the member for
Yorkton. And you know, the member for Yorkton, I had the opportunity to just
follow him here in the speaking order. But again, as a new MLA, you come to the
building, you’re trying to figure out your way. And the member from Yorkton
kind of ended up in our office space, maybe not by choice, but he ended up in
140.
And you know what? I’ll never forget.
You know, the member always says, bitter and better, the difference is only one
vowel. And you know, I’m sure grateful that that gentleman wakes up every
morning and chooses to be better because it really has made our caucus and our
government better for it.
So anyway I just want to wish the folks
that are, you know, not running again, I thank them for their service and
certainly for the work that they’ve done on behalf of their constituents for
the betterment of this province.
I just want to talk about the 2024
budget, and then I’ll have some closing thoughts about choices and a choice
that we have again this year sometime in late October. But I’d like to quickly
talk about how the 2024‑2025 budget, it was obviously good for the
province, but it’s great for The Battlefords.
And I’m really excited. You know, this
budget, it’s a $20 billion budget. And again, I’ve had the opportunity to
be a part of the budget development process in previous years, but this budget
is one that is very exciting for my part of the province. I’ll say that because
I think what this budget clearly does is it shows that, you know, as our
province has grown, as our economy is growing, it means that we can invest in a
major way into the services that we all deserve and expect as Saskatchewan
residents.
I mean, you think about it, Mr. Speaker:
a 9 per cent overall increase to the education budget. A 10 per cent increase
to the health care budget, already the largest budget in the province, Mr.
Speaker, and we’re adding 10 points to it. And then you think about the
municipal revenue-sharing dollars, the dollars that go right back into our communities
so that our locally elected mayors and reeves and councillors can make
decisions on municipal infrastructure.
[16:45]
That, Mr. Speaker, has gone up 14 per
cent, and I just quickly looked back. There’s a great municipal revenue-sharing
dashboard on the Saskatchewan website. I encourage many people to go check it
out. And so I just took North Battleford and Battleford, and from 2007 to 2024,
how has municipal revenue sharing increased on an annual basis? Well let me
tell you. In 2007, North Battleford’s municipal revenue share dollars was
1.16 million. Mr. Speaker, in 2024 it’s $3.28 million.
On the other side of the river, the town
of Battleford — you know, smaller community — started out in 2007 at $407,000
and is now at $1.22 million. Mr. Speaker, think about that for a second.
The dollars that are shared with our municipalities so that they can make
decisions about roads or rinks or water infrastructure in their communities, in
The Battlefords that has tripled since the Sask Party
became government in 2007. Municipal dollars tripled since Sask
Party became government. And again, what those dollars are able to be invested
in.
And you look at, you know, sometimes I
hear in my community, what’s changed? What’s changed since last year? What’s
changed since five years ago? I’d say quite a bit has changed. We’re improving
our infrastructure. We’re adding services in our respective communities. And
really I see just incredible potential for growth in our part of the province,
Mr. Speaker. Now obviously, as I said earlier, when we have a strong and
growing economy and we’re able to share more dollars with municipalities,
there’s also other services that are needed, right? We’ve got more people
living in our community.
You know, when it comes to health care,
Mr. Speaker, and I have shared these numbers previously in this House, but I
just find these numbers to be very important to talk about once again. You
know, our Health ministers and the previous Health ministers have done an
incredible job in terms of setting out the most ambitious health human
resources action plan in this country, Mr. Speaker. And through that health
human resources action plan, we have the rural and remote recruitment incentive
program, Mr. Speaker.
So you know, at last count there were
about 330 positions, full-time positions that had been filled through that
incentive province-wide, which is fantastic. Fantastic to see full-time
positions in communities in the North, communities in rural areas of the
province, and positions in small cities like North Battleford or Yorkton be
filled so that we can make sure that more health care services can be offered
close to home, Mr. Speaker. Sixty-eight of those 338 positions, Mr. Speaker,
have been in my community, 68 of 330. The Battlefords have been the most
successful community in the whole province when it comes to recruiting for the
rural and remote recruitment incentive, Mr. Speaker.
So when we combine those numbers, Mr.
Speaker, you know, we have upwards of 50 to 60 new full-time nurses in The
Battlefords. That is impressive, Mr. Speaker. And you know, from the other side
of the House every single day, Mr. Speaker, we hear crisis and crisis and
crisis and crisis. And, Mr. Speaker, there is absolutely more work to do,
absolutely more work to do in terms of recruiting the right people to our
community, ensuring that the right services can be offered in all of our
respective communities but, Mr. Speaker, that is something that this government
is working on every single day and our progress is showing, Mr. Speaker.
Mr. Speaker, I’ll quickly also talk
about addictions. If I have time later I’ll come back to this, Mr. Speaker, but
you know when I look at the direction that this government is taking on
addictions and recovery in this province, it makes me very proud because we
have seen approaches in other provinces, Mr. Speaker, that actually do the
opposite of what they’re intended to do, Mr. Speaker.
NDP BC [British Columbia], this is a
prime example, Mr. Speaker. The decriminalization efforts that have been going
on in BC, they’re not working, Mr. Speaker. Again that’s the province I grew up
in. I have friends, I have family there, Mr. Speaker. At the end of the day,
when it comes to working with people who are suffering from addictions in our community,
making access to illicit drugs easier, Mr. Speaker, normalizing that, that is
not going to result in recovery. It’s just a faster path to death, Mr. Speaker.
And I would say in our families, in our
communities, that’s not what we want. We want recovery, Mr. Speaker. We want
people, we want our family members, we want our neighbours, Mr. Speaker — we
know many of them are struggling — but we want them to get on a better path and
we want them to find recovery so that they can once again be engaged in their
families and their communities, Mr. Speaker.
And, Mr. Speaker, you know, the NDP
approach to this is completely opposite. The NDP approach to this
. . . Many of the members on the other side, they want to go to the
BC model and then they want to go even further, Mr. Speaker. That’s not what is
best, Mr. Speaker. Whether you live in town or whether you live on a reserve,
that is not the best approach. That approach will kill people in this province,
Mr. Speaker.
Every day, Mr. Speaker, members on that
side of the House get up and talk about deaths via overdose. Mr. Speaker, those
numbers are only going to go up if we follow what the NDP plan is on drug
policy, Mr. Speaker. A drug policy that results in more death in our community
is not a drug policy. It’s a death policy, Mr. Speaker. And that’s what the
members opposite have, quite frankly.
Mr. Speaker, I also want to talk about,
you know, some additional investments that we have made in the post-secondary
space in The Battlefords, Mr. Speaker. We have a fantastic institution, North
West College, which has campuses in both Meadow Lake and North Battleford, Mr.
Speaker. And what we’ve seen over the last several years is North West College,
which was already a key partner in terms of health care training, become an
even more valuable part of the puzzle, Mr. Speaker, as we work to train and
recruit and retain and incentivize more health care workers to work right in
our community.
Mr. Speaker, since I became the MLA for
The Battlefords, we have doubled the number of registered psych nursing seats
available every year at North West College. We started in 2020 with 16 seats in
the cohort, Mr. Speaker, available every year. We’ve added to that a couple of
years ago, Mr. Speaker. We’ve added to that in this budget, in this ’24‑25
budget, Mr. Speaker. Now we have 32 seats available in the registered psych
nursing program at North West College, Mr. Speaker. And isn’t that fantastic?
Because we have a $400 million provincial psych hospital in our community,
one of the largest employers in The Battlefords, Mr. Speaker.
I’d also highlight some changes that
we’ve made to the RN [registered nurse] program at North West College, Mr.
Speaker. Through partnerships with the University of Saskatchewan, Mr. Speaker,
people who come to North West College can now do their entire four-year
registered nursing program right at home in The Battlefords, Mr. Speaker. That
is fantastic news for kids that want to stay close to home and eventually work
and live in the community they grew up in, Mr. Speaker.
You know, and as I’ve worked with North
West College, as I’ve worked with my colleagues in the Ministry of Advanced
Education and in the Ministry of Health to advance these things, Mr. Speaker,
over the last several years, I can’t help but think about the incredible
opportunities available to health care grads in The Battlefords. Mr. Speaker,
if you think about it, number one, there’s jobs available. There’s jobs
available. Whether it is in North Battleford proper or whether it’s in Wilkie
or Turtleford or Unity, Mr. Speaker, there are jobs in our part of the
province. And good jobs, Mr. Speaker, jobs that pay the bills, jobs that pay
the mortgage, Mr. Speaker, jobs with really good paycheques, Mr. Speaker.
The other piece is that, you know, again
in this province we have a relatively low cost of living, Mr. Speaker. Compared
to other provinces, Mr. Speaker, Saskatchewan is a very affordable place to
live. You can buy a house here, Mr. Speaker, and start to grow your family in
this province.
But then going back to what’s available
for health care grads, you start to think about the stacking benefits of some
of these incentives, Mr. Speaker. So again, the rural and remote recruitment
incentive, Mr. Speaker, for a registered nurse or registered psych nurse,
that’s a $50,000 cash incentive for a three-year return of service. Then you
add the graduate retention program, Mr. Speaker, which I know members opposite
have derided and, you know, view with derision, Mr. Speaker. But the graduate
retention program is absolutely key in terms of ensuring that our students and
our graduates stay in this province and build their lives here. So that’s a
$20,000 rebate, Mr. Speaker.
So now we’re at 70,000, Mr. Speaker. And
if you think about what the nursing loan forgiveness program adds to that, Mr.
Speaker, which was just added to North Battleford among several other
communities just this year, Mr. Speaker, that adds another up to $20,000
incentive.
So now, Mr. Speaker, you can receive
your full four-year training right in The Battlefords. Then you can get a job
in The Battlefords, Mr. Speaker, and there’s nearly $100,000 of incentives
available for you as you start your career. That is absolutely incredible,
absolutely incredible, Mr. Speaker.
Mr. Speaker, I’ll move to education. And
I speak every day in this House about education and the investments that our
government makes into K to 12 education in this province, Mr. Speaker. I’ve
already said we’ve got the largest ever school operating increase in funding,
Mr. Speaker, that this province has ever seen: 8.1 per cent to the 27 school
divisions around the province.
You know what, Mr. Speaker? In our
community, Living Sky School Division is going to see a year-over-year 6.5 per
cent increase to school operating funding. Light of Christ Catholic School
Division will see a 9.6 per cent increase. Mr. Speaker, those are significant
increases, which means that our local school divisions, you know, now have more
capacity to hire more teachers, hire more EAs [educational assistant], hire
more professionals to better support students in our part of the province, Mr.
Speaker.
You know, Mr. Speaker, I’ll also
highlight: The Battlefords are one of the focus communities for the specialized
support classroom pilot project, which aims to provide dedicated space in
specific schools where students who need additional assistance can be provided
with those supports before being reintegrated back into their home classroom.
You know, in our community, Mr. Speaker,
we’re seeing this work done at McKitrick Community
School; we’re seeing this work done at St. Mary School, Mr. Speaker. And so
both these schools are receiving additional funding to hire more staff to
support students and again, you know, to address some of the challenges that we
see in our classrooms, Mr. Speaker, but also to make sure kids are better
served. Kids and families will be better served through this pilot project, and
we look forward to seeing that come through.
You know, Mr. Speaker, I’ll maybe just
talk specifically . . . I want to talk about the carbon tax very
quickly. You know, and the cost — I’m not sure if I’ve shared these numbers in
the House — the cost to school divisions around the province, Mr. Speaker, of
the carbon tax, we estimate that to be an $11 million cost province-wide,
$11 million that’s going to pay a carbon tax that doesn’t work,
that could be spent in our classrooms, Mr. Speaker, that could be spent on
buses, Mr. Speaker, to make sure that kids get to school safely, Mr. Speaker.
I was talking with a friend the other
day about a lot of politicians have this new-found opposition to the carbon
tax, including some of the members opposite, Mr. Speaker. And it’s interesting,
because you know, my friend and I were kind of chuckling. You know, come
election time do you want the real thing or do you want a cheap replica?
And, Mr. Speaker, when I think about the
real thing, that’s this Premier. This Premier who was Environment minister at
the time, Mr. Speaker, who walked out when this policy was shoved down the
throats of the province, Mr. Speaker, he’s the real thing. The member opposite,
the Leader of the Opposition, the leader of the Saskatchewan NDP, is a cheap
replica when it comes to opposition of the carbon tax, Mr. Speaker. I don’t
know about you. And you know what? I’ve got a lot of respect for the people of
this province. They know better. And come election time, Mr. Speaker, I do
believe that will show, Mr. Speaker.
Mr. Speaker, I’ve spent a bit of time
recently trying to become a student of British political history. And you know,
it’s something to do in the evening, something to do on the weekend, Mr.
Speaker. And, Mr. Speaker, I found a particular interest in reading some of
Margaret Thatcher’s old quotes, Mr. Speaker. And, Mr. Speaker, I just want to
share. I want to share one that I believe is relevant, Mr. Speaker, relevant to
the choice that we have in October. Let me quote this:
Imagine a Labour
canvasser [or an NDP canvasser in this case] talking on the doorstep to those
East German families when they settle in on freedom’s side of the wall. You
want to keep more of the money you earn? I’m afraid that’s very selfish. We
shall want to tax that away. You want to own shares in your own firm? We can’t
have that. The state has to own your firm. You want to choose where to send
your children to school? Oh, that’s very divisive. You’ll send your child where
we tell you.
Mr. President, the
problem with Labour [or the NDP] is that they’re just not at home with freedom.
Socialists don’t like ordinary people choosing, for they might not choose
socialism.
Mr. Speaker, and I think, Mr. Speaker,
Thatcher’s analysis of the Labour Party of the day in the UK [United Kingdom],
Mr. Speaker, is very apt for the Saskatchewan NDP of 2024, Mr. Speaker. They’ve
got lots of criticism on where to spend dollars. They don’t know where to find
the dollars though, Mr. Speaker. They don’t know where to find it, Mr. Speaker.
Mr. Speaker, you know, they have lots of
thoughts on how they want to tax windfall profits in the industries that drive
forward this province, Mr. Speaker. They have no understanding of how those
industries work, Mr. Speaker. And don’t be fooled. They will nationalize those
industries if they get a chance, Mr. Speaker.
And when it comes to choosing where your
children get to go to school, Mr. Speaker, whether it’s a public school or a
Catholic school or an independent school in this province, Mr. Speaker, those
members want to take it away. They want to tell you where you can and cannot
send your children to school, Mr. Speaker. And that’s just not right, Mr.
Speaker. We’re going to have a choice in October — socialism or continuing to
grow this province, Mr. Speaker.
I’m going to be supporting this budget,
Mr. Speaker. Thank you very much.
The
Deputy Speaker: — The time now being 5 o’clock, this
Assembly stands adjourned until 10 o’clock tomorrow morning.
[The Assembly adjourned at 17:00.]
Published
under the authority of the Hon. Randy Weekes, Speaker
Disclaimer:
The electronic versions of the Legislative Assembly's documents are provided
for information purposes only. The content of the documents is identical to the
printed record; only the presentation differs unless otherwise noted. The
printed versions are the official record for legal purposes.